Falsely Arrested in Newport Beach or Irvine? What Happens Next in Orange County

Police Misconduct Attorney Newport Beach

My office sits on Birch Street in Newport Beach. I have practiced from this community for decades, and I can tell you something people here do not expect: false arrests happen in nice neighborhoods too. One of my clients was arrested in Newport Beach over a dispute about a $16 cab ride. That case settled for $360,000. Quiet streets do not mean careful police.

Quick Answer

If you were falsely arrested in Newport Beach or Irvine, write down everything, photograph any injuries, and talk to a lawyer before your court date. Criminal cases from both cities are heard at the Harbor Justice Center in Newport Beach. If you want to sue, a government claim against the city usually must be filed within six months of the arrest.

What should you do after a false arrest in Newport Beach or Irvine?

Act quickly, while evidence and memories are fresh. Most of what wins a false arrest case is gathered in the first few weeks: the names, the video, the medical records, and your own written account. Here are the steps, in order.

  1. Write your account today. Include the time, place, officers’ names or badge numbers, what was said, and who was there.
  2. Photograph injuries and get medical care, even for marks that seem minor. Bruising from handcuffs and takedowns shows up over days.
  3. List witnesses and cameras. Fashion Island, Balboa Peninsula, and the Irvine Spectrum area are full of business and doorbell cameras. Many overwrite footage within days.
  4. Keep your paperwork: the citation, booking or release documents, property receipt, and bail papers.
  5. Do not post about the arrest or discuss it with anyone but your lawyer.
  6. Calendar your deadlines: your court date, and the six-month government claim deadline if you may sue.
  7. Talk to a lawyer who handles both criminal defense and civil rights. What you say in your criminal case can help or hurt the civil one.

Where will your case be heard?

Criminal and traffic cases from Newport Beach and Irvine are handled at the Harbor Justice Center, 4601 Jamboree Road in Newport Beach. The Orange County Superior Court assigns that courthouse to both cities, along with Laguna Beach, Mission Viejo, Lake Forest, and much of south Orange County, according to the court’s location page.

That matters more than people think. The young lawyer knows the law, but the old lawyer knows the judge. Every courthouse has its own habits: how prosecutors there handle “resistance” cases, how closely judges examine a weak police report, and how quickly cases tend to move. A lawyer who regularly practices in Orange County understands those habits.

If the arresting officer was with Newport Beach PD or Irvine PD, the district attorney decides whether to file charges. Sometimes no charges are ever filed. That is common in false arrest cases, and it is good news, but it is not the end of the story.

What if you were released without any charges?

If the police arrested you and then released you because there were not enough grounds for a criminal complaint, California Penal Code 849 says the arrest is deemed a detention only, not an arrest. You can also ask the court to declare you factually innocent under Penal Code 851.8, which seals and destroys the arrest record if granted.

People assume that because nothing was filed, there is nothing to do. But an arrest record can follow you into a background check, a job application, or a professional license review. Under Penal Code 851.8, a person who shows there was no reasonable cause for the arrest can petition for a finding of factual innocence. It is a demanding standard, and it is worth pursuing when the facts support it.

Being released without charges also tends to strengthen a civil claim. If the police had no case worth filing, a jury may wonder why they had a reason to arrest you in the first place.

Can you sue the city of Newport Beach or Irvine for a false arrest?

Yes. A false arrest is an arrest without probable cause, and it can support claims under federal civil rights law and California law. For state-law claims against a city, you must first file a government claim, generally within six months of the arrest under Government Code 911.2, before you can file a lawsuit.

For the City of Newport Beach, the city’s own claim form directs claims to the City Clerk at 100 Civic Center Drive. Claims against Irvine go to that city, and claims involving Orange County Sheriff’s deputies go to the county. Each has its own form. Getting the right entity, on time, is not optional; a missed claim deadline can wipe out the state-law part of your case.

Federal civil rights claims under 42 U.S.C. 1983 do not require a government claim, and they generally borrow California’s two-year personal injury limit in Code of Civil Procedure 335.1. I explain the six-month rule in more detail in The 6-Month Government Claim Deadline.

What makes an arrest “false” in California?

An arrest is false when the officer lacked probable cause, meaning facts that would lead a reasonable person to believe you committed a crime. Being arrested for something you did not do is not always enough; the question is what the officer knew at the time. An arrest made to punish you for questioning the officer is classic false arrest.

In my experience, the most common false arrests in affluent communities start with “Contempt of Cop.” Someone asks why they are being detained, records the officer, or refuses a search they have every right to refuse. The officer feels disrespected, and suddenly there is a “resisting” charge or a “drunk in public” charge that never would have happened if the person had stayed silent. I covered the full legal framework in Suing the Police for False Arrest in Southern California.

Talk to a false arrest lawyer close to home

Steering Law is based in Newport Beach and represents people falsely arrested by Newport Beach police, Irvine police, and Orange County Sheriff’s deputies. Learn more on our Newport Beach police misconduct and Irvine police misconduct pages, or about our false arrest practice. Call (949) 474-1849 for a consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

At the Harbor Justice Center, 4601 Jamboree Road in Newport Beach, which serves both cities and much of south Orange County.

A government claim against a city or county is generally due within six months. Federal civil rights claims generally must be filed within two years. Confirm your deadlines with a lawyer.

The city’s claim form directs claims to the City Clerk at 100 Civic Center Drive, Newport Beach.

Under Penal Code 849, if officers release you because there were insufficient grounds for a complaint, the arrest is deemed a detention only. You may also petition for factual innocence under Penal Code 851.8.

Possibly. Dismissal does not automatically prove a false arrest, but it can support one. The key question is whether the officer had probable cause.

It can be. Being handcuffed and held can be a seizure that requires legal justification, depending on how long and why.

You need a lawyer who knows civil rights law and the local courts. Familiarity with the Harbor Justice Center and Orange County agencies is a real advantage.

About the Author

Jerry L. Steering, Esq. has been suing police officers and defending bogus “resistance offense” criminal cases throughout California since 1984. A graduate of the University of Georgia School of Law (1984), he is admitted to practice in California, Georgia, the Ninth and Eleventh Circuits, and the United States Supreme Court. His police-misconduct cases have produced settlements and verdicts in the millions, and his work has been featured on ABC News, CNN, Good Morning America, Dateline NBC, The Washington Post, and the Los Angeles Times. He practices from Newport Beach and serves clients across Southern California.

Legal Disclaimer

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this post or contacting Steering Law through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different; if you are facing a legal issue, you should consult a qualified California attorney about your specific situation. Past results do not guarantee similar outcomes.

Sources

  1. Superior Court of California, County of Orange, Harbor Justice Center: https://www.occourts.org/location/harbor-justice-center-newport-beach
  2. City of Newport Beach, General Liability Claim form: https://www.newportbeachca.gov/home/showpublisheddocument/77754/639039037024800000
  3. California Government Code section 911.2 (claim deadline) (California Legislative Information): https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=GOV&sectionNum=911.2
  4. California Penal Code section 849 (release without charges) (California Legislative Information): https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=PEN&sectionNum=849
  5. California Penal Code section 851.8 (factual innocence) (California Legislative Information): https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=PEN&sectionNum=851.8
  6. California Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1 (two-year limit) (California Legislative Information): https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=CCP&sectionNum=335.1