Author: Jerry L. Steering, Esq.

Steering Law is a California-based civil rights and criminal defense firm led by Jerry L. Steering, Esq. The firm focuses on police misconduct cases, including excessive force, false arrest, malicious prosecution, contempt of cop incidents, and 42 U.S.C. §1983 civil rights actions, while also handling serious criminal defense matters. Steering Law is dedicated to protecting clients’ constitutional rights and delivering justice for individuals who have been wronged by law enforcement.
Rancho San Diego Sheriff's Station

Can You Sue the Sheriff or Police Chief Personally for What Their Deputies Did?

People call my office all the time and say, “I want to sue the Sheriff.” I understand the impulse. The deputies who beat you or falsely arrested you work for him, wear his badge, and follow his policies. So why shouldn’t the man at the top answer for it? I have been suing police officers and their bosses since 1984, and the honest answer is that the law makes this much harder than it should be. Here is how it works.

Quick Answer

Yes, but only in limited situations. Under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, a sheriff or police chief is not automatically liable for what deputies or officers do. You must show the supervisor’s own conduct caused the violation: setting it in motion, knowingly allowing it to continue, or showing deliberate indifference to a known pattern. Qualified immunity still applies, and the October 2026 Villanueva ruling shows how hard that test can be.

Can you sue a sheriff or police chief personally under Section 1983?

Yes, you can name a sheriff or police chief as an individual defendant, but only for his own wrongful conduct. Federal civil rights law does not allow “vicarious liability,” which means a supervisor is not liable just because he is the boss. You must connect his personal actions, or his deliberate inaction, to your injury.

The federal civil rights statute, 42 U.S.C. § 1983, lets you sue anyone who, acting under color of state law, violates your constitutional rights. The Supreme Court has said that each government official is liable only for his or her own misconduct. In the real world, the Sheriff gets to say, “I wasn’t there,” and often that ends it.

But not always. The Ninth Circuit has long recognized that a supervisor can be held personally liable when there is “a sufficient causal connection” between what he did and what happened to you.

When is a supervisor personally liable for a deputy’s misconduct?

A supervisor can be personally liable when he set in motion a series of acts he knew or should have known would violate someone’s rights, knowingly refused to stop that misconduct, was culpably indifferent in training or supervising his people, or acquiesced in a pattern of violations he knew about.

Those categories come straight out of the Ninth Circuit’s model civil jury instructions on supervisory liability, which rely heavily on Starr v. Baca, 652 F.3d 1202 (9th Cir. 2011). In Starr, a jail inmate sued then-Los Angeles County Sheriff Lee Baca personally. The Ninth Circuit held that a supervisor’s knowing acquiescence in unconstitutional conduct by subordinates can itself be the supervisor’s own wrongdoing.

In practice, the cases that survive look like this:

  • Repeated warnings ignored. The Sheriff received reports, audits, or lawsuits describing the same abuse and did nothing.
  • Approval or encouragement. The chief ratified or praised the use of force, as in Larez v. City of Los Angeles (9th Cir. 1991), a case involving a police chief who approved or encouraged excessive force by his officers.
  • Direct orders. The supervisor personally directed the operation that caused the harm.

A general complaint that “the Sheriff runs a bad department” does not work.

What happened in the Villanueva qualified immunity case?

On October 21, 2026, the Ninth Circuit held that former Los Angeles County Sheriff Alex Villanueva was entitled to qualified immunity in a lawsuit by protesters who said deputies shot them with projectiles during a 2020 demonstration. The court found no clearly established law prohibiting his specific supervisory conduct.

The case is Astorga v. Villanueva, No. 24-4061. Villanueva was not at the demonstration. The district court had allowed the claim against him to go forward; the Ninth Circuit reversed. The panel distinguished Larez and cited the Supreme Court’s 2026 decision in Zorn v. Linton, which again demanded a prior case with closely matching facts before an official loses immunity.

Two things matter here. First, the ruling is an unpublished memorandum, so it is not binding precedent. Second, the court did not decide whether the deputies themselves acted lawfully. This is how the system works: the people with the most power get the most protection, and the “clearly established law” test does the heavy lifting. I have written before about why qualified immunity is a curse, and this case is a textbook example.

Is suing the sheriff personally different from suing the county?

Yes. A claim against the sheriff personally targets his own conduct and is subject to qualified immunity. A claim against the county or city targets its policies, customs, or failure to train. Qualified immunity does not protect the entity itself, which is why the two claims are often brought together.

Under federal law, a county or city can be liable for its own unconstitutional policy or custom, but not simply because it employs the deputy. That is the Monell doctrine. State law is different. Under California Government Code § 815.2, a public entity is generally liable for injuries caused by an employee acting within the scope of employment. That is one reason I almost always plead state claims alongside federal ones, including claims under the Tom Bane Civil Rights Act. I explained the differences in Qualified Immunity vs. the Bane Act.

If you plan to bring state-law claims against a California public entity, you generally must file a government claim within six months under Government Code § 911.2. Miss it and those claims may be gone.

How do you prove a sheriff knew about a pattern of abuse?

You prove it with records. Prior complaints, internal affairs findings, use-of-force data, audits, earlier lawsuits and settlements, and personnel records released under California’s transparency laws can show the supervisor knew and did nothing. Without that paper trail, the claim against the supervisor rarely survives.

This is detective work, and it starts early:

  1. Request public records on prior use-of-force complaints and sustained findings for the department.
  2. Gather published court decisions and settlements involving the same unit or station.
  3. Look for audit reports, inspector general findings, or grand jury reports.
  4. Identify what training and policies were in place, and whether they were followed.
  5. Preserve your own evidence, including video, photos, and medical records.

A supervisor claim that rests on a single incident almost never works. A claim built on years of documented warnings sometimes does.

Should you name the sheriff in your lawsuit?

Sometimes. Naming a sheriff or chief makes sense when you have specific facts showing his personal involvement or deliberate indifference. Naming him without those facts invites an early motion to dismiss and a qualified immunity appeal that can delay your case for a year or more.

When a court denies qualified immunity, the officer can usually appeal right away, and the whole case can sit still while the appeal is decided. Strategy matters. “Make the wrong step and you are out. We know where to step.” Sometimes the smartest move is to go after the deputies and the county, and leave the Sheriff for another day.

If you were hurt or falsely arrested by deputies anywhere in Los Angeles County, Orange County, or elsewhere in Southern California, talk to a lawyer who litigates federal civil rights lawsuits every day. You can learn more about our police misconduct practice or request a free case evaluation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Only if you can show the sheriff’s own conduct caused the violation, such as ordering it, knowingly allowing it, or ignoring a known pattern. Being the boss is not enough under Section 1983.

Supervisory liability is a claim that a supervisor is personally responsible for a constitutional violation because of his own actions or deliberate indifference, not simply because he supervises the officer who did it.

Yes. Sued personally, a sheriff or chief can claim qualified immunity, and the court asks whether clearly established law prohibited his specific supervisory conduct.

No. Astorga v. Villanueva is an unpublished Ninth Circuit memorandum, which generally is not binding precedent in future cases.

Yes. A county can be liable under Section 1983 for its own policies, customs, or failure to train, and under California law for employees acting within the scope of employment.

No. Qualified immunity protects individual officials. It does not protect the public entity itself.

Generally, a government claim must be presented within six months of the incident under Government Code section 911.2. Talk to a lawyer right away to protect your deadlines.

Prior complaints, sustained internal affairs findings, audits, earlier lawsuits and settlements, use-of-force data, and released personnel records can show knowledge and inaction.

About the Author

Jerry L. Steering, Esq. has been suing police officers and defending bogus “resistance offense” criminal cases throughout California since 1984. A graduate of the University of Georgia School of Law (1984), he is admitted to practice in Georgia (1984) and California (1986, State Bar No. 122509), the Ninth and Eleventh Circuit Courts of Appeals, and the United States Supreme Court. His police misconduct cases have produced settlements and verdicts in the millions, and his work has been featured on ABC News, CNN, Good Morning America, Dateline NBC, The Washington Post, and the Los Angeles Times. He practices from Newport Beach and serves clients across Southern California. Call (949) 474-1849 or request a free case evaluation.

Legal Disclaimer

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this post or contacting Steering Law through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different; if you are facing a legal issue, you should consult a qualified California attorney about your specific situation. Past results do not guarantee similar outcomes.

Sources
  1. U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, Astorga v. Villanueva, No. 24-4061 (Oct. 21, 2026), memorandum: https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/memoranda/2026/10/21/24-4061.pdf
  2. Davis Vanguard, “Ninth Circuit Grants Former LA County Sheriff Qualified Immunity in Lawsuit over Force Used against Protesters”: https://davisvanguard.org/2026/10/villanueva-granted-qualified-immunity/
  3. Ninth Circuit Manual of Model Civil Jury Instructions, 9.4, Section 1983 Claim Against Supervisory Defendant: https://www.ce9.uscourts.gov/jury-instructions/civil/chapter-9/9-4-section-1983-claim-against-supervisory-defendant-in-individual-capacity-elements-and-burden-of-proof/
  4. Starr v. Baca, 652 F.3d 1202 (9th Cir. 2011), FindLaw: https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-9th-circuit/1575276.html
  5. Dorsey & Whitney, March 23, 2026 Supreme Court Update (Zorn v. Linton): https://www.dorsey.com/newsresources/publications/client-alerts/2026/3/march-23-supreme-court-update
  6. 42 U.S.C. § 1983, Cornell Legal Information Institute: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/1983
  7. California Government Code § 815.2: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=GOV&sectionNum=815.2
  8. California Government Code § 911.2: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=GOV&sectionNum=911.2

Can a Cop Fired for Misconduct Be Rehired in California?

For most of my career, a bad cop who got fired in one city could simply move down the freeway and get hired in another. Departments did not always share files, and California was one of the few states with no way to strip an officer of his license to police. Police reform advocates called it the “wandering officer” problem. SB 2 finally changed that.

Quick Answer

Not easily anymore. Since January 1, 2022, California’s SB 2 has allowed the state’s police standards agency, POST, to suspend or revoke an officer’s certification for serious misconduct such as excessive force, dishonesty, or a knowingly false arrest. A decertified officer cannot work as a peace officer in California. A new law taking effect January 1, 2027 extends similar rules to former immigration enforcement officers.

Can a police officer who was fired for misconduct get another police job in California?

Often not, if the misconduct was serious. Under SB 2, California’s Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) can revoke an officer’s certification. Without certification, the officer cannot serve as a peace officer anywhere in the state, no matter which department wants to hire him.

Before SB 2 took effect in 2022, POST could issue certificates but had almost no power to take them away for misconduct. An officer fired for lying in reports or beating a handcuffed suspect could resign before the discipline was final, keep a clean certificate, and apply elsewhere. That loophole was real, and it put dangerous people back on the street.

Decertification closes most of that gap. It follows the officer, not the department. And under Penal Code 13510.8, agencies must finish investigating serious misconduct regardless of the officer’s employment status, so resigning does not make a pending investigation disappear.

What misconduct can get an officer decertified?

California law defines nine categories of “serious misconduct” that can lead to suspension or revocation, according to POST’s Guide to Decertification:

  1. Dishonesty in reporting, investigating, or prosecuting a crime or misconduct
  2. Abuse of power, including intimidating witnesses or knowingly making a false arrest
  3. Physical abuse, including excessive or unreasonable force
  4. Sexual assault
  5. Bias based on a protected status, in violation of law or policy
  6. Egregious or repeated acts that violate the law
  7. Participation in a law enforcement gang
  8. Failure to cooperate with a misconduct investigation
  9. Failure to intercede when another officer uses clearly excessive force

Look at number two. “Knowingly making a false arrest” is now, in itself, a ground for losing a badge. So is dishonesty in a police report. Those are exactly the things I see in “Contempt of Cop” cases, where an officer arrests someone for disrespecting him and then writes a report to justify it.

How does the decertification process work?

A complaint or agency report goes to POST’s Peace Officer Standards Accountability Division, which investigates. If it finds reasonable grounds, a nine-member advisory board reviews the case and makes a recommendation. Revocation requires clear and convincing evidence and a two-thirds vote of the Commission, followed by the officer’s right to an administrative hearing.

Departments are required to report serious misconduct allegations to POST. Members of the public can also file complaints directly with POST under Penal Code 13509.5, which is something most people do not know. If you were the victim of serious misconduct, you do not have to rely on the department to report its own officer.

Importantly, much of the process is public. Under Penal Code 13510.85, board hearings and the records introduced in them are open, even though police personnel files are normally confidential. POST also publishes the names of officers whose certification has been suspended or revoked, along with the basis.

What does the new MELT ICE Act change?

Starting January 1, 2027, AB 1627, the Misconduct Ends Law-Enforcement Trust Act of 2026, extends California’s peace officer disqualification rules to former immigration enforcement officers who committed serious misconduct. Prior immigration enforcement work alone is not disqualifying; it is the misconduct that counts.

According to an October 7 analysis by Liebert Cassidy Whitmore, the law brings federal, out-of-state, and territorial officers who engage in immigration enforcement under Government Code 1029. If they committed misconduct serious enough that POST would have revoked a California officer’s certificate for it, they cannot be hired as California peace officers.

The Governor vetoed a broader bill, AB 1896, which would have barred hiring based on participation in certain immigration enforcement activity even without a misconduct finding. In his veto message he called that approach a step too far.

How does decertification help a civil rights lawsuit?

Decertification is an administrative action, not a lawsuit, and it does not pay you anything. But public decertification findings and prior misconduct records can be powerful evidence in a civil case, especially in claims that the city or county knew about an officer’s history and kept him on the street anyway.

That kind of claim is called a Monell claim, and it lets you hold the government entity itself responsible for its own policies, customs, or failures to train and supervise. I explain it in Suing the City, Not Just the Officer: Monell Claims in California. An officer with a documented history of serious misconduct, still on patrol, is often the starting point for one.

SB 2 also changed California’s Bane Act so that it applies more clearly to police misconduct, a change I covered in What Is Qualified Immunity, and Can California’s SB 2 Get Around It? Taken together, these reforms mean the system is finally asking whether bad officers should keep their badges, not just whether their victims can get paid.

What should you do if an officer’s misconduct seems serious enough for decertification?

Protect your own case first. Before you file any complaint, with POST or with the department, talk to a civil rights lawyer. A complaint is a written statement, and anything in it can be used against you later, including in a criminal case built on a “resistance” charge.

  1. Preserve your evidence: photos, medical records, video, and witness names.
  2. Calendar the six-month government claim deadline if you may sue a city or county.
  3. Decide with your lawyer when and how to file a POST complaint, so it helps your case rather than hurting it.

Hurt by an officer with a history?

If you were injured or falsely arrested by an officer you believe has done this before, talk to a lawyer before you file anything. Steering Law handles police misconduct cases throughout Southern California, including Orange County communities like Irvine. Call (949) 474-1849 for a consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

It is the suspension or revocation of a peace officer’s state certification by POST, which prevents the officer from serving as a peace officer anywhere in California.

SB 2 took effect January 1, 2022, creating the current misconduct-based decertification system.

Resigning does not end a pending investigation. Under Penal Code 13510.8, agencies must complete serious misconduct investigations regardless of the officer’s employment status.

Yes. “Abuse of power,” which includes knowingly making a false arrest, is one of the nine categories of serious misconduct.

Yes. Members of the public can submit complaints of serious misconduct directly to POST, in addition to complaining to the officer’s department.

Many are. Board hearings, certain Commission reviews, and records introduced in those proceedings are public under Penal Code 13510.85, and POST publishes the names of decertified officers.

AB 1627, effective January 1, 2027, extends California’s peace officer disqualification rules to former immigration enforcement officers who committed serious misconduct.

About the Author

Jerry L. Steering, Esq. has been suing police officers and defending bogus “resistance offense” criminal cases throughout California since 1984. A graduate of the University of Georgia School of Law (1984), he is admitted to practice in California, Georgia, the Ninth and Eleventh Circuits, and the United States Supreme Court. His police-misconduct cases have produced settlements and verdicts in the millions, and his work has been featured on ABC News, CNN, Good Morning America, Dateline NBC, The Washington Post, and the Los Angeles Times. He practices from Newport Beach and serves clients across Southern California.

Legal Disclaimer

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this post or contacting Steering Law through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different; if you are facing a legal issue, you should consult a qualified California attorney about your specific situation. Past results do not guarantee similar outcomes.

Sources
  1. California POST, Guide to Decertification: https://post.ca.gov/portals/0/post_docs/resources/sb2/Guide_to_Decertification.pdf
  2. California Penal Code section 13510.8 (California Legislative Information): https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=PEN&sectionNum=13510.8
  3. California Penal Code section 13510.85 (public proceedings) (California Legislative Information): https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=PEN&sectionNum=13510.85
  4. Liebert Cassidy Whitmore, “Governor Newsom Signs the MELT ICE Act of 2026, Broadening the Basis for Peace Officer Disqualification, and Vetoes the GTFO Act,” Oct. 7, 2026: https://www.calpublicagencylaboremploymentblog.com/legislation/governor-newsom-signs-the-melt-ice-act-of-2026-broadening-the-basis-for-peace-officer-disqualification-and-vetoes-the-gtfo-act/
  5. Hanson Bridgett, “Law Enforcement Officer Decertification” (SB 2 implementation overview): https://www.hansonbridgett.com/publication/230306-6070-leo-decertification
  6. California Government Code section 1029 (peace officer disqualification) (California Legislative Information): https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=GOV&sectionNum=1029
Police Misconduct Attorney Newport Beach

Falsely Arrested in Newport Beach or Irvine? What Happens Next in Orange County

My office sits on Birch Street in Newport Beach. I have practiced from this community for decades, and I can tell you something people here do not expect: false arrests happen in nice neighborhoods too. One of my clients was arrested in Newport Beach over a dispute about a $16 cab ride. That case settled for $360,000. Quiet streets do not mean careful police.

Quick Answer

If you were falsely arrested in Newport Beach or Irvine, write down everything, photograph any injuries, and talk to a lawyer before your court date. Criminal cases from both cities are heard at the Harbor Justice Center in Newport Beach. If you want to sue, a government claim against the city usually must be filed within six months of the arrest.

What should you do after a false arrest in Newport Beach or Irvine?

Act quickly, while evidence and memories are fresh. Most of what wins a false arrest case is gathered in the first few weeks: the names, the video, the medical records, and your own written account. Here are the steps, in order.

  1. Write your account today. Include the time, place, officers’ names or badge numbers, what was said, and who was there.
  2. Photograph injuries and get medical care, even for marks that seem minor. Bruising from handcuffs and takedowns shows up over days.
  3. List witnesses and cameras. Fashion Island, Balboa Peninsula, and the Irvine Spectrum area are full of business and doorbell cameras. Many overwrite footage within days.
  4. Keep your paperwork: the citation, booking or release documents, property receipt, and bail papers.
  5. Do not post about the arrest or discuss it with anyone but your lawyer.
  6. Calendar your deadlines: your court date, and the six-month government claim deadline if you may sue.
  7. Talk to a lawyer who handles both criminal defense and civil rights. What you say in your criminal case can help or hurt the civil one.

Where will your case be heard?

Criminal and traffic cases from Newport Beach and Irvine are handled at the Harbor Justice Center, 4601 Jamboree Road in Newport Beach. The Orange County Superior Court assigns that courthouse to both cities, along with Laguna Beach, Mission Viejo, Lake Forest, and much of south Orange County, according to the court’s location page.

That matters more than people think. The young lawyer knows the law, but the old lawyer knows the judge. Every courthouse has its own habits: how prosecutors there handle “resistance” cases, how closely judges examine a weak police report, and how quickly cases tend to move. A lawyer who regularly practices in Orange County understands those habits.

If the arresting officer was with Newport Beach PD or Irvine PD, the district attorney decides whether to file charges. Sometimes no charges are ever filed. That is common in false arrest cases, and it is good news, but it is not the end of the story.

What if you were released without any charges?

If the police arrested you and then released you because there were not enough grounds for a criminal complaint, California Penal Code 849 says the arrest is deemed a detention only, not an arrest. You can also ask the court to declare you factually innocent under Penal Code 851.8, which seals and destroys the arrest record if granted.

People assume that because nothing was filed, there is nothing to do. But an arrest record can follow you into a background check, a job application, or a professional license review. Under Penal Code 851.8, a person who shows there was no reasonable cause for the arrest can petition for a finding of factual innocence. It is a demanding standard, and it is worth pursuing when the facts support it.

Being released without charges also tends to strengthen a civil claim. If the police had no case worth filing, a jury may wonder why they had a reason to arrest you in the first place.

Can you sue the city of Newport Beach or Irvine for a false arrest?

Yes. A false arrest is an arrest without probable cause, and it can support claims under federal civil rights law and California law. For state-law claims against a city, you must first file a government claim, generally within six months of the arrest under Government Code 911.2, before you can file a lawsuit.

For the City of Newport Beach, the city’s own claim form directs claims to the City Clerk at 100 Civic Center Drive. Claims against Irvine go to that city, and claims involving Orange County Sheriff’s deputies go to the county. Each has its own form. Getting the right entity, on time, is not optional; a missed claim deadline can wipe out the state-law part of your case.

Federal civil rights claims under 42 U.S.C. 1983 do not require a government claim, and they generally borrow California’s two-year personal injury limit in Code of Civil Procedure 335.1. I explain the six-month rule in more detail in The 6-Month Government Claim Deadline.

What makes an arrest “false” in California?

An arrest is false when the officer lacked probable cause, meaning facts that would lead a reasonable person to believe you committed a crime. Being arrested for something you did not do is not always enough; the question is what the officer knew at the time. An arrest made to punish you for questioning the officer is classic false arrest.

In my experience, the most common false arrests in affluent communities start with “Contempt of Cop.” Someone asks why they are being detained, records the officer, or refuses a search they have every right to refuse. The officer feels disrespected, and suddenly there is a “resisting” charge or a “drunk in public” charge that never would have happened if the person had stayed silent. I covered the full legal framework in Suing the Police for False Arrest in Southern California.

Talk to a false arrest lawyer close to home

Steering Law is based in Newport Beach and represents people falsely arrested by Newport Beach police, Irvine police, and Orange County Sheriff’s deputies. Learn more on our Newport Beach police misconduct and Irvine police misconduct pages, or about our false arrest practice. Call (949) 474-1849 for a consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

At the Harbor Justice Center, 4601 Jamboree Road in Newport Beach, which serves both cities and much of south Orange County.

A government claim against a city or county is generally due within six months. Federal civil rights claims generally must be filed within two years. Confirm your deadlines with a lawyer.

The city’s claim form directs claims to the City Clerk at 100 Civic Center Drive, Newport Beach.

Under Penal Code 849, if officers release you because there were insufficient grounds for a complaint, the arrest is deemed a detention only. You may also petition for factual innocence under Penal Code 851.8.

Possibly. Dismissal does not automatically prove a false arrest, but it can support one. The key question is whether the officer had probable cause.

It can be. Being handcuffed and held can be a seizure that requires legal justification, depending on how long and why.

You need a lawyer who knows civil rights law and the local courts. Familiarity with the Harbor Justice Center and Orange County agencies is a real advantage.

About the Author

Jerry L. Steering, Esq. has been suing police officers and defending bogus “resistance offense” criminal cases throughout California since 1984. A graduate of the University of Georgia School of Law (1984), he is admitted to practice in California, Georgia, the Ninth and Eleventh Circuits, and the United States Supreme Court. His police-misconduct cases have produced settlements and verdicts in the millions, and his work has been featured on ABC News, CNN, Good Morning America, Dateline NBC, The Washington Post, and the Los Angeles Times. He practices from Newport Beach and serves clients across Southern California.

Legal Disclaimer

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this post or contacting Steering Law through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different; if you are facing a legal issue, you should consult a qualified California attorney about your specific situation. Past results do not guarantee similar outcomes.

Sources

  1. Superior Court of California, County of Orange, Harbor Justice Center: https://www.occourts.org/location/harbor-justice-center-newport-beach
  2. City of Newport Beach, General Liability Claim form: https://www.newportbeachca.gov/home/showpublisheddocument/77754/639039037024800000
  3. California Government Code section 911.2 (claim deadline) (California Legislative Information): https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=GOV&sectionNum=911.2
  4. California Penal Code section 849 (release without charges) (California Legislative Information): https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=PEN&sectionNum=849
  5. California Penal Code section 851.8 (factual innocence) (California Legislative Information): https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=PEN&sectionNum=851.8
  6. California Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1 (two-year limit) (California Legislative Information): https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=CCP&sectionNum=335.1
RCSD Shooting

Can the Police Keep Shooting After You’re Down?

No, not if the person no longer poses an immediate threat. Courts judge police force by what was reasonable at each moment, not just at the start. If a person has been wounded, has fallen, and is not attacking or trying to get up, later shots can be unconstitutional. In June 2025, the full Ninth Circuit held that a jury could find an LAPD officer’s last two shots, fired after the man had fallen, were unlawful. The Supreme Court declined to review that ruling in June 2026. California’s deadly force law, Penal Code 835a, is also stricter than the federal rule.

Key points:

  • Force that was justified at the start can become excessive once the threat ends.
  • When the danger is over, the shooting must stop.
  • California law is stricter than the federal minimum.
  • The number of shots alone is not the test. The timing between shots matters.
  • Video and physical evidence usually decide these cases.
  • You generally have only six months to file a government claim.
  • Survivors and families can sue for civil rights violations.

 In every police shooting case we handle, the story comes down to seconds. Officers say it all happened too fast to think. That can be true for the first shot. It is rarely true for the last one.

The law says what common sense always has: when the danger ends, the shooting has to end too. This guide explains how courts decide that, why officers often fire so many times, what rights you have if you were shot by police, and what to do next.

Quick Answer

Not necessarily. Under Ninth Circuit law, force that was justified at the start of an encounter can become excessive once the threat ends. In June 2025, the full Ninth Circuit held a jury could find that an LAPD officer’s final two shots, fired after the man had fallen, were unconstitutional. The Supreme Court declined to disturb that ruling in June 2026.

Can police keep shooting someone who is already down?

Not if the person no longer poses an immediate threat. The Ninth Circuit holds that officers must reassess as an encounter unfolds. Force that was reasonable a moment earlier can become excessive once a suspect is wounded, on the ground, and not trying to get up or attack. A jury can decide whether the later shots crossed that line.

The constitutional test comes from Graham v. Connor (1989): was the force “objectively reasonable” under the circumstances the officer faced? The key word is circumstances, plural. They change. A man charging with a knife is one circumstance. The same man curled on the pavement after being shot four times is another.

California’s own deadly force statute points the same direction. Since 2020, Penal Code 835a has allowed an officer to use deadly force only when necessary to defend against an imminent threat of death or serious bodily injury. Once the threat is gone, the justification is gone with it.

When Is a Police Shooting Legal? The Rules Officers Must Follow

Deadly force is legal only when an officer reasonably believes there is an immediate threat of death or serious injury to the officer or someone else. Everything else, including the number of shots, is judged against that rule.

The Federal Test: Graham v. Connor

The Supreme Court set the basic rule in Graham v. Connor: was the force “objectively reasonable” under the circumstances the officer faced?

What “Objectively Reasonable” Means

Courts ask what a reasonable officer would have done in that same situation, without hindsight. The key word is circumstances. A man charging with a knife is one situation. That same man lying on the pavement after being shot is another. Circumstances change second by second, and the law expects the officer to notice.

Shooting a Fleeing Suspect: Tennessee v. Garner

In Tennessee v. Garner, the Supreme Court ruled that police cannot use deadly force on a fleeing suspect who poses no significant danger. Running away is not enough. The officer needs a reasonable belief that the person threatens death or serious harm.

California’s Stricter Rule: Penal Code 835a

Since 2020, California Penal Code 835a has allowed deadly force only when it is necessary to defend against an imminent threat of death or serious bodily injury. Once the threat is gone, the legal reason for deadly force is gone with it.

Federal vs. California Deadly Force Standard

QuestionFederal (Fourth Amendment)California
Basic standardObjectively reasonable forceDeadly force only when necessary
What courts look atTotality of the circumstancesTotality of the circumstances, with a necessity requirement
Fleeing suspectAllowed only if a significant threatSame, and the force must still be necessary
Who decidesOften a juryOften a jury

Why Do Police Shoot So Many Times? (And Why It Doesn’t Make It Legal)

Most families ask us the same thing: why so many shots? The honest answer is training, stress, and human limits. But none of these explanations makes extra shots legal when the threat has ended.

“Trained to Shoot Until the Threat Stops”

Officers are generally trained to keep firing until the threat is neutralized and not to pause in the middle. According to CNN’s reporting, experts say stopping to assess could give a suspect time to hurt someone. That training is why officers say they “kept firing.” The problem arises when the threat has already ended and the officer keeps going.

Stress, Sympathetic Fire, and Reaction Time

Several things push shot counts up:

  • Sympathetic fire. When one officer fires, others may fire too, even if they have not seen a threat themselves.
  • Stress and memory. Officers in high-stress shootings often cannot say how many shots they fired. Some report a few shots when the real number was much higher.
  • Missed shots. A 2019 Dallas study found officers hit their targets only about 35% of the time, so more rounds go out.
  • Reaction time. Police trainers point to perception-reaction time, generally 0.7 to 1.5 seconds. In a Force Science Institute test of 102 officers, the slowest fired six more trigger pulls after a signal to stop.

What evidence decides a police shooting case?

Video, timing, and physical evidence. These cases turn on what happened between each shot: where the person was, which way he was moving, and whether he was still a threat. Body camera and dash camera footage, the autopsy or medical records, the location of shell casings, and witness accounts usually decide whether a jury hears the case.

In Hernandez, the video showed the timing of each shot. In Zion, the dashcam contradicted the deputy’s testimony that the man was trying to get up. Officers’ reports are written after the fact, often after they have watched the footage. The footage itself does not change its story.

If your family is dealing with a police shooting, these are the first steps:

  1. Preserve every piece of evidence you have, including phone video, texts, and photos.
  2. Identify witnesses and cameras in the area quickly, before footage is overwritten.
  3. Request the video. California law generally requires agencies to release critical incident video within 45 days, with limited exceptions. I explain the process in How to Get the Body Camera Footage of Your Arrest in California.
  4. Mind the six-month deadline for a government claim against the city or county.
  5. Talk to a civil rights attorney before giving any statement to investigators.

If a loved one died, there are often two kinds of claims, which I explain in What’s the Difference Between a Wrongful Death and an Excessive Force Claim After a Police Shooting?

What the Defense Will Argue, and Why It Doesn’t End the Case

Expect the city or county to say the officer simply could not stop fast enough. It is a real argument, and we take it seriously. But it has limits. In the Hernandez case, the officer fired six shots in about six seconds, and the court still held that a jury could decide the last two were unlawful. The question is not whether the officer is human. The question is whether the force was reasonable at that moment.

Common Police Explanation vs. How It Holds Up

ExplanationWhat it meansHow we challenge it
“It all happened fast.”Officer had no time to thinkFrame-by-frame video shows when each shot was fired and what the person was doing
“I wasn’t counting my shots.”Officer can’t recall the numberBody cam, audio, and casing locations show the real count
“Other officers were firing.”Sympathetic fireEach officer is responsible for their own force
“I couldn’t stop in time.”Reaction-time delayCourts still ask if the later shots were reasonable and let juries decide

Court Rulings That Changed Police Shooting Law

A few decisions now shape every police shooting case in California.

Estate of Hernandez v. City of Los Angeles (Ninth Circuit, 2025)

In 2020, after a multi-car crash in Los Angeles, Daniel Hernandez got out holding a box cutter and moved toward an officer. She fired six shots in roughly six seconds. The full Ninth Circuit found the first four shots reasonable. But it held that a jury could find the last two, fired after he had fallen and was rolling away, were unconstitutional. The court denied the officer qualified immunity on those shots. On June 22, 2026, the Supreme Court declined to hear the city’s appeal, and the case returns to the trial court.

Zion v. County of Orange (2017)

In Zion, a deputy kept shooting a man who had collapsed and then stomped on his head. The Ninth Circuit held that a jury could find that was excessive force. That decision put California officers on notice, and the Hernandez court relied on it. We wrote about it when it came down: a deputy can be sued for shooting a suspect and then stomping on his head.

Barnes v. Felix (U.S. Supreme Court, 2025)

In 2025, the Supreme Court unanimously rejected the “moment of threat” rule, which looked only at the split second an officer felt afraid. Courts must now weigh the whole situation, including events leading up to the shooting. That helps victims, because an officer’s earlier choices count too.

Why Qualified Immunity Matters

Qualified immunity protects officers unless an earlier case clearly told them their conduct was unlawful. It is a major hurdle in these lawsuits. Decisions like Zion help clear it. California also gives victims other tools, which we explain in qualified immunity vs. the Bane Act.

Shot by Police? Your Rights as a Victim

If you or a family member were shot by police, you are not powerless. You have several ways to review what happened and to hold officers accountable.

Your Right to Request Video and Records

California law generally requires agencies to release video of critical incidents, including shootings, within about 45 days, with limited exceptions. You can also ask for reports and other records. Our guide explains how to get the body camera footage of your arrest. Your attorney can also use the legal process to demand records that police refuse to hand over.

Your Right to File a Complaint

You can file a complaint with the police department, and it will be investigated internally. But an internal review is not a lawsuit. It rarely brings compensation, and the department is judging itself. Many victims do both: file the complaint and pursue a civil case.

Your Right to Sue for Civil Rights Violations

You can sue for civil rights violations in state or federal court. Common claims include:

  • Excessive force under the Fourth Amendment, brought through 42 U.S.C. § 1983
  • Violations of California’s Bane Act
  • Wrongful death, if the person died
  • Claims against the city or county, not only the officer

Types of Police Brutality Cases Involving Shootings

Police brutality cases come in many forms. These are the shooting-related situations we see most:

  • Shot while surrendering or with hands raised
  • Shot in the back while turning or moving away
  • Unarmed person shot
  • Additional shots after the person is already down
  • Shooting during a welfare check or mental health crisis
  • Shooting after the officer created the danger
  • Fatal shootings that lead to wrongful death claims

The legal path can differ depending on whether the person survived. We explain the difference in wrongful death vs. excessive force claims after a police shooting.

What to Do After a Police Shooting: Step-by-Step

The first days matter more than most people realize. Evidence disappears quickly.

  1. Get medical care and keep every record. Hospital notes, bills, and photos of injuries are evidence.
  2. Save all video, photos, and messages. Phone footage, texts, and social posts can matter.
  3. Find witnesses and cameras fast. Businesses and doorbell cameras often overwrite footage within days.
  4. Request the official video and reports. Do this early, and keep copies.
  5. Do not give a statement to investigators yet. Talk to a civil rights attorney first.
  6. Watch the government claim deadline. This is the one people miss. Read about the six-month government claim deadline.

Key Deadlines

StepTypical deadlineNote
Government claim against a city or county6 monthsGenerally required before suing
Civil rights lawsuitGenerally 2 yearsCan differ by claim type
Request body camera videoAgencies generally release within about 45 daysLimited exceptions apply

Deadlines vary by case. Speak to an attorney as soon as you can.

What Evidence Wins a Police Shooting Case?

These cases usually turn on what happened between each shot. The strongest evidence includes:

  • Body camera and dash camera footage
  • The timing of each shot
  • Medical records or the autopsy
  • The location of shell casings
  • Independent witness accounts
  • Officer reports compared against the video

Reports are often written after officers have watched the footage. The footage itself does not change. In Zion, the dashcam contradicted the deputy’s claim that the man was trying to get up.

Can You Win Compensation After a Police Shooting?

Many survivors and families recover compensation, but every case is different. Possible damages include medical bills, lost income, pain and suffering, and, in wrongful death cases, losses suffered by the family. Punitive damages may be available in some cases.

Our firm obtained $2.9 million for a motorist shot by Anaheim police. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

Why Choose Steering Law for a Police Shooting Case

Steering Law has represented people hurt by police since 1984. Jerry L. Steering has spent four decades suing police departments and defending people charged after police force. We represent people shot by police, and families of those killed, across Southern California, including Orange, Los Angeles, Riverside, San Bernardino, and San Diego counties.

We know how these cases are won: early evidence, frame-by-frame video review, and a clear understanding of qualified immunity. If you need a police shooting attorney, call Steering Law at (949) 474-1849 for a consultation.

Bottom Line

The law does not let an officer keep shooting once the threat is over. Courts look at each moment, California’s rule is stricter than the federal one, and video and timing usually decide the case. Deadlines are short, so waiting can cost you your claim. If you or someone you love was shot by police, talk to Steering Law at (949) 474-1849 before you speak to investigators

Frequently Asked Questions

Not if the person no longer poses an immediate threat. A person who is wounded, down, and not attacking can no longer justify deadly force. A jury can decide whether later shots crossed that line.

Sometimes, but only if the person still posed an immediate threat. Officers sometimes argue the person turned during the shooting. Video and timing usually show whether the threat had ended when the shot was fired.

Generally not. Under Tennessee v. Garner, police cannot shoot a fleeing person who poses no significant danger. The officer must reasonably believe the person threatens death or serious injury.

Police are trained to aim at the largest part of the body. Experts quoted by FRONTLINE say hitting a leg under stress is unrealistic, a leg wound can still be fatal, and missed shots can hit bystanders. That does not excuse unlawful force.

Often yes. A resisting charge does not automatically block a civil rights case, though it can complicate it. Speak to an attorney before taking a plea.

You generally have six months to file a government claim, and about two years to file a lawsuit. Deadlines can vary, so act quickly.

Legal Disclaimer

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this post or contacting Steering Law through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different; if you are facing a legal issue, you should consult a qualified California attorney about your specific situation. Past results do not guarantee similar outcomes.

Sources
  1. Estate of Hernandez v. City of Los Angeles, Nos. 21-55994, 21-55995 (9th Cir. June 2, 2025) (en banc): https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2025/06/02/21-55994.pdf
  2. Officer.com, “Supreme Court Says Former Los Angeles Police Officer May be Sued for Excessive Force in Shooting,” June 23, 2026: https://www.officer.com/command-hq/news/55386028/supreme-court-says-former-los-angeles-police-officer-may-be-sued-for-excessive-force-in-shooting
  3. Zion v. County of Orange, 874 F.3d 1072 (9th Cir. 2017) (Courthouse News coverage): https://www.courthousenews.com/9th-circuit-revives-suit-oc-police-killing/
  4. Barnes v. Felix, 605 U.S. ___ (2025) (Cornell LII): https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/23-1239
  5. Graham v. Connor, 490 U.S. 386 (1989) (Justia): https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/490/386/
  6. California Penal Code section 835a (California Legislative Information): https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=PEN&sectionNum=835a

Robin Winger is taken from her truck during DUI arrest by Garden Grover officers. (Courtesy of Attorney Jerry Steering)

Are DUI Checkpoints Legal in California? Your Rights Before Halloween Weekend

Halloween falls on a Saturday this year, and holiday weekends often bring sobriety checkpoints across Southern California. Most people roll through in two minutes and drive home. But every year I hear from people whose two-minute stop turned into a search, a detention, or a pair of handcuffs, without the reasonable suspicion the Constitution requires. Here is what the police can and cannot do.

Quick Answer

Yes. DUI checkpoints are legal in California when they follow the safeguards the California Supreme Court set in Ingersoll v. Palmer (1987). Supervisors must plan them, officers must stop cars by a neutral formula, the stop must be brief, and the checkpoint must be clearly marked. If police skip those rules, or hold you without reasonable suspicion, the stop can be unlawful.

Are DUI checkpoints legal in California?

Yes, with conditions. The U.S. Supreme Court upheld sobriety checkpoints in Michigan Department of State Police v. Sitz (1990). Three years earlier, the California Supreme Court in Ingersoll v. Palmer held California checkpoints lawful only when they follow specific guidelines designed to limit officer discretion and keep the intrusion small.

Think about how unusual a checkpoint is. Normally an officer needs reasonable suspicion that you did something wrong before he can stop your car. At a checkpoint, he stops you with no suspicion at all. Courts allow that narrow exception because of the public safety interest in drunk driving. But the exception only holds if the checkpoint stays inside its limits. The Supreme Court made that clear in City of Indianapolis v. Edmond (2000), which struck down a checkpoint whose real purpose was general crime control, such as looking for drugs.

What rules must a California DUI checkpoint follow?

Ingersoll v. Palmer identified eight factors courts use to decide whether a checkpoint is constitutional:

  1. Supervisory decision-making. Command staff, not field officers, decide to set up the checkpoint and set its rules.
  2. Limits on officer discretion. Cars are stopped by a neutral formula, such as every car or every third car, not by an officer’s hunch.
  3. Safety. Proper lighting, signs, and traffic control protect drivers and officers.
  4. Reasonable location. The site should reflect a real drunk-driving problem, such as a high rate of DUI collisions.
  5. Time and duration. The timing should make sense, such as weekend nights.
  6. Indicia of official nature. Signs, marked cars, and uniformed officers show that it is a legitimate checkpoint.
  7. Length and nature of detention. Each stop should be brief, enough to look for signs of intoxication and nothing more.
  8. Advance publicity. Public notice helps reduce the intrusion and the surprise, and serves the deterrent purpose.

No single factor is a magic switch, but a checkpoint that ignores several of them is vulnerable.

Do you have to stop at a DUI checkpoint in California?

Yes. Vehicle Code section 2814.2 requires a driver to stop and submit to a sobriety checkpoint inspection when signs and displays direct the stop. The same statute bars police from impounding your car at a checkpoint when the only offense is driving without a license, if a licensed driver can take it.

That impound rule is worth knowing. For years, checkpoints were criticized as tow-truck revenue machines, and the legislature responded. Under Vehicle Code 2814.2, if the registered owner, or a licensed driver the owner authorizes, can take the car by the end of the checkpoint, it should be released to that person.

Can you avoid a checkpoint before you reach it? Making a lawful turn onto another street is generally not, by itself, a crime. But if you make an illegal U-turn or commit any other traffic violation to avoid it, an officer can pull you over for that violation. I covered how far “any traffic violation” stretches in my post on Whren v. United States.

What can the police ask you at a DUI checkpoint?

At the initial stop, officers may briefly observe you, ask for your license and registration, and ask a few general questions. You must provide your license and registration. You do not have to answer questions about where you have been or whether you have been drinking; you may politely decline.

This is where checkpoints go sideways. The initial stop is supposed to be brief and suspicionless. Anything more, being ordered out of the car, field sobriety tests, a search of your vehicle, requires something more: reasonable suspicion that you are impaired or that some other crime is happening. “He seemed nervous” is not enough. Neither is the fact that you exercised your right not to answer.

A few practical points:

  • Field sobriety tests (walking a line, following a pen) are generally voluntary. You can politely decline.
  • The roadside breath test (the preliminary alcohol screening, or PAS) is generally optional for drivers 21 and over who are not on DUI probation, under Vehicle Code 23612.
  • The chemical test after a lawful DUI arrest is different. California’s implied consent law requires it, and refusing has real penalties.
  • Your car cannot be searched just because you are at a checkpoint. Officers need consent, probable cause, or another legal basis.

Stay calm, keep your hands visible, and do not argue at the window. A checkpoint is the worst possible place to “fail the attitude test.” Be polite, be brief, and save the fight for court.

When does a checkpoint stop become an illegal detention?

A checkpoint stop becomes unlawful when it is longer or more intrusive than the brief screening the courts approved, without reasonable suspicion to justify it. Holding you for extended questioning, searching your car without consent or probable cause, or arresting you without probable cause can all violate the Fourth Amendment.

Those are the cases I care about. A driver who had nothing to drink gets pulled into secondary screening because an officer did not like his answers. A passenger gets ordered out and patted down for no reason. A sober person gets arrested because she declined a field sobriety test, then spends a night in jail before the blood results clear her. When that happens, there may be a claim for unlawful detention or false arrest. For the distinction between those two claims, see Do California Police Have to Tell You Why You’re Being Detained?

Wrongly detained or arrested at a checkpoint?

If a checkpoint stop turned into a search, an arrest, or force you did not deserve, talk to a lawyer about your rights. Steering Law handles false arrest and unlawful detention cases throughout Southern California from our Newport Beach office. Call (949) 474-1849 for a consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, if they follow the guidelines set by the California Supreme Court in Ingersoll v. Palmer (1987), including supervisory planning, neutral selection of cars, and brief stops.

Yes. Vehicle Code 2814.2 requires drivers to stop when signs and displays direct them to.

A lawful turn before the checkpoint is generally not illegal by itself. Any traffic violation you commit while avoiding it can justify a stop.

You must show your license and registration. You can politely decline to answer questions about where you have been or whether you have been drinking.

Not just because you are at a checkpoint. A search requires consent, probable cause, or another recognized legal basis.

Under Vehicle Code 2814.2, not if that is the only offense and a licensed driver authorized by the owner can take the car by the end of the checkpoint.

The roadside preliminary screening test is generally optional for drivers 21 and over who are not on DUI probation. The chemical test after a lawful DUI arrest is required under implied consent law.

About the Author

Jerry L. Steering, Esq. has been suing police officers and defending bogus “resistance offense” criminal cases throughout California since 1984. A graduate of the University of Georgia School of Law (1984), he is admitted to practice in California, Georgia, the Ninth and Eleventh Circuits, and the United States Supreme Court. His police-misconduct cases have produced settlements and verdicts in the millions, and his work has been featured on ABC News, CNN, Good Morning America, Dateline NBC, The Washington Post, and the Los Angeles Times. He practices from Newport Beach and serves clients across Southern California.

Legal Disclaimer

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this post or contacting Steering Law through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different; if you are facing a legal issue, you should consult a qualified California attorney about your specific situation. Past results do not guarantee similar outcomes.

Sources
  1. Ingersoll v. Palmer, 43 Cal.3d 1321 (1987) (CourtListener): https://www.courtlistener.com/?q=%22Ingersoll+v.+Palmer%22
  2. Michigan Dept. of State Police v. Sitz, 496 U.S. 444 (1990) (Justia): https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/496/444/
  3. City of Indianapolis v. Edmond, 531 U.S. 32 (2000) (Justia): https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/531/32/
  4. California Vehicle Code section 2814.2: https://california.public.law/codes/vehicle_code_section_2814.2
  5. California Vehicle Code section 23612 (implied consent and preliminary alcohol screening) (California Legislative Information): https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=VEH&sectionNum=23612
US Supreme Court as of 8-7-25

Penal Code 69 vs. 148(a)(1): What’s the Difference, and Why Does It Matter?

When the police beat someone up, they need a reason. The reason is almost always the same: “he resisted.” In my four decades of suing police officers, I have seen that story attached to nearly every excessive force case that crosses my desk. The charge they reach for is either Penal Code 148(a)(1) or Penal Code 69. I call them “Resistance Offenses,” and they are the system’s favorite hammer.

Quick Answer

Penal Code 148(a)(1) is a misdemeanor for willfully resisting, delaying, or obstructing an officer, punishable by up to one year in county jail. Penal Code 69 is a “wobbler” for using threats or violence to deter an officer, or knowingly resisting with force or violence; it can be charged as a felony. Either conviction can block a later civil rights lawsuit.

What is the difference between PC 69 and PC 148(a)(1)?

Penal Code 148(a)(1) covers anyone who willfully resists, delays, or obstructs an officer doing his job. Penal Code 69 is more serious: it requires a threat or violence used to deter an officer, or knowingly resisting the officer with force or violence. Section 148 is always a misdemeanor; section 69 can be a felony.

 Penal Code 148(a)(1)Penal Code 69
Common nameResisting, delaying, or obstructing an officerResisting an executive officer
What it coversWillfully resisting, delaying, or obstructing an officer in the performance of dutyUsing threats or violence to deter an officer, or knowingly resisting with force or violence
LevelMisdemeanorWobbler (felony or misdemeanor)
Maximum jailUp to 1 year in county jailUp to 1 year in county jail as a misdemeanor; felony sentencing under Penal Code 1170(h)
Maximum fine$1,000$10,000
Force required?NoYes, threat or violence (or force when resisting)

You can read the statutes yourself in Penal Code 148 and Penal Code 69.

Why would prosecutors charge PC 69 instead of 148?

Leverage. A felony-eligible PC 69 charge frightens people into pleading guilty to the misdemeanor PC 148(a)(1). The California Supreme Court held in People v. Smith (2013) that 148(a)(1) can be a lesser included offense of the force-or-violence version of section 69, which makes that trade easy for a prosecutor to offer.

Here is how it plays out. An officer uses force he should not have used. He writes a report saying you “pulled away,” “tensed up,” or “took a fighting stance.” The district attorney files PC 69, and you face the possibility of a felony record. Then the offer comes: plead to a misdemeanor 148, maybe no jail, and go home.

Most people take it. They are scared, they have jobs and kids, and they want it over. I understand that. But that plea often does something nobody explained to them. It can quietly destroy the civil case against the officer who hurt them.

How does a resisting arrest conviction affect a civil rights lawsuit?

Under Heck v. Humphrey (1994), you cannot bring a civil rights claim that would necessarily imply your criminal conviction is invalid. If you pleaded guilty to resisting a lawful arrest, a claim that the arrest itself was unlawful usually fails. The California Supreme Court applied the same rule to state-law claims in Yount v. City of Sacramento (2008).

That is why I say these charges are filed to protect the police, not the public. A conviction for a “Resistance Offense” does two jobs for the department at once: it justifies the force on paper, and it can bar you from suing over it. I wrote about this trap in detail in Can You Plead Out and Still Sue the Police?

There is an important limit. The Ninth Circuit held in Hooper v. County of San Diego (2011) that a 148(a)(1) conviction does not automatically bar an excessive force claim. If you resisted at one moment and the officer then used excessive force at another, both things can be true, and the civil claim may survive. Whether it survives depends heavily on exactly what you pleaded to and the factual basis stated in court.

Can you be convicted if you only argued with the officer?

Not under these statutes alone. Words, questions, and even angry criticism of an officer are generally protected by the First Amendment. Section 148 requires willful resistance, delay, or obstruction of an officer performing a lawful duty, and section 69 requires threats, violence, or force. Talking back is not a crime.

What the officer calls “resistance” is often what I call “Contempt of Cop.” You asked why you were being stopped. You did not move fast enough. You pulled your arm away when it was twisted in a way that hurt. You “Failed the Attitude Test.” None of that is a crime, but every bit of it shows up in a police report as obstruction.

The other element prosecutors often cannot prove is that the officer was lawfully performing his duties. An officer who detains you without reasonable suspicion, or arrests you without probable cause, is not acting lawfully. You cannot be convicted of resisting an unlawful arrest under 148(a)(1). That is one of the first things I look at in every case.

What should you do if you are charged with PC 69 or 148?

  1. Do not accept a plea before talking to a lawyer who also handles civil rights cases. Your criminal defense strategy and your civil case are connected.
  2. Get your injuries documented by a doctor and photographed right away.
  3. Request the body camera and dash camera video through your defense attorney.
  4. Write down every witness and every camera that might have recorded the encounter.
  5. Do not discuss the incident on social media or with anyone except your lawyer.

The young lawyer knows the law, but the old lawyer knows the judge. With these cases, knowing how the system tends to treat “resistance” claims, and where the soft spots are in the officer’s story, matters as much as knowing the statutes. Make the wrong step and you are out. We know where to step.

Get help from a lawyer who handles both sides

Steering Law has defended bogus resisting arrest and contempt of cop cases for decades, and we sue the officers who file them. For background, see my articles on Penal Code 69, “The Hammer of Oppression” and Penal Code 148(a)(1). If you are facing a charge in Orange County, our Newport Beach criminal defense team can help. Call (949) 474-1849 before you accept any plea.

Frequently Asked Questions

It can be. PC 69 is a “wobbler,” meaning the prosecutor can file it as a felony or a misdemeanor.

No. Resisting, delaying, or obstructing an officer under 148(a)(1) is a misdemeanor, punishable by up to one year in county jail and a fine of up to $1,000.

Often, yes. Prosecutors frequently offer a plea to 148(a)(1) in exchange for dropping PC 69, but that plea can have serious consequences for a civil lawsuit.

Sometimes. A conviction can bar claims that would undermine it, but an excessive force claim based on force used at a different moment may still proceed.

It depends on the facts, including whether the officer was acting lawfully and whether the movement was a reflex to pain. These details are often disputed.

A lawful performance of duty is an element of both offenses. If the detention or arrest was unlawful, that is a major defense.

Generally no. Speech alone, including criticism of an officer, is usually protected by the First Amendment and is not resisting under 148(a)(1).

About the Author

Jerry L. Steering, Esq. has been suing police officers and defending bogus “resistance offense” criminal cases throughout California since 1984. A graduate of the University of Georgia School of Law (1984), he is admitted to practice in California, Georgia, the Ninth and Eleventh Circuits, and the United States Supreme Court. His police-misconduct cases have produced settlements and verdicts in the millions, and his work has been featured on ABC News, CNN, Good Morning America, Dateline NBC, The Washington Post, and the Los Angeles Times. He practices from Newport Beach and serves clients across Southern California.

Legal Disclaimer

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this post or contacting Steering Law through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different; if you are facing a legal issue, you should consult a qualified California attorney about your specific situation. Past results do not guarantee similar outcomes.

Sources
  1. California Penal Code section 69 (Justia, 2025 code): https://law.justia.com/codes/california/code-pen/part-1/title-5/section-69/
  2. California Penal Code section 148 (Justia, 2025 code): https://law.justia.com/codes/california/code-pen/part-1/title-7/chapter-7/section-148/
  3. Heck v. Humphrey, 512 U.S. 477 (1994) (Justia): https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/512/477/
  4. Yount v. City of Sacramento, 43 Cal.4th 885 (2008) (CourtListener): https://www.courtlistener.com/?q=%22Yount+v.+City+of+Sacramento%22
  5. Hooper v. County of San Diego, 629 F.3d 1127 (9th Cir. 2011) (CourtListener): https://www.courtlistener.com/?q=Hooper+v.+County+of+San+Diego+629+F.3d+1127
  6. People v. Smith, 57 Cal.4th 232 (2013) (CourtListener): https://www.courtlistener.com/?q=%22People+v.+Smith%22+57+Cal.4th+232
ICE raid at Bell CA carwash SUMMER 2025

SB 747 Is Now Law: Can You Sue an ICE Agent in California?

For decades, if a city cop beat you, you could sue him. If an ICE or Border Patrol agent did the exact same thing on the exact same street, you were mostly out of luck. That gap just closed. I have been suing police officers since 1984, and this is one of the most significant changes to California civil rights law I have seen.

Quick Answer

Yes. On September 29, 2026, Governor Newsom signed SB 747, the “No Kings Act,” now California Civil Code section 53.8. It lets you sue anyone acting under color of law, federal agents included, for violating your constitutional rights. It took effect immediately, reaches violations on or after March 1, 2025, and allows recovery of attorney fees. Officers can still raise qualified immunity.

What does SB 747 actually do?

SB 747 creates a California cause of action, codified at Civil Code section 53.8, against any person who violates your rights under the United States Constitution while acting under color of law. That includes federal law. ICE, Border Patrol, and other federal agents are no longer outside the reach of a state-law civil rights claim.

Here is why that matters. The main federal civil rights statute, 42 U.S.C. section 1983, only reaches people acting under color of state law. City police, sheriff’s deputies, and CHP officers fall under it. Federal agents never did. For them, the courts invented a substitute called a Bivens claim, and then spent forty years shrinking it. In Egbert v. Boule (2022), the Supreme Court made a new Bivens claim against a Border Patrol agent nearly impossible to bring.

So California wrote its own remedy. According to the Daily Journal’s reporting, the law:

  • Took effect immediately when signed on September 29, 2026
  • Applies to violations that occurred on or after March 1, 2025
  • Allows a prevailing plaintiff to recover reasonable attorney fees, costs, and expert fees
  • Preserves sovereign immunity and lets defendants raise the same immunities available in a section 1983 case

Can you sue an ICE agent for a false arrest or excessive force?

Yes, if the agent violated a right the Constitution protects. A false arrest without probable cause violates the Fourth Amendment. So does unreasonable force during a stop, detention, or arrest. Under Civil Code 53.8, those are the same kinds of claims California residents already bring against local police.

Think about what has been happening on Southern California streets during immigration enforcement operations. The people stopped have not all been immigrants; U.S. citizens have been detained too, and some have been hurt. Before SB 747, a citizen held without probable cause had very few good options against the individual agent who did it. Now that citizen has a California statute written for exactly that situation.

The first cases are already moving. Fox LA reported that three Californians amended pending lawsuits against the Department of Homeland Security and unnamed federal agents on the same day the Governor signed the bill.

Does qualified immunity still protect federal agents?

Yes, it can. Civil Code 53.8 lets defendants assert absolute or qualified immunity to the same extent they could in a section 1983 case. So an agent can still argue that no prior case clearly established that his particular conduct was unconstitutional. SB 747 opens the courthouse door; it does not remove that defense.

I have been fighting “qualified immunity” my entire career, and I will tell you plainly: it is the single biggest obstacle in civil rights litigation. Judges invented it, and judges apply it generously to police. You can read more about how it works, and how California’s SB 2 already works around it for state claims, in my post on qualified immunity and SB 2.

Why the legislature kept the defense is a fair question. My read is practical: keeping the same immunity rules that apply to local police makes the law harder to attack as discriminating against federal officers. In February, a federal judge preliminarily concluded that California’s police mask law unlawfully discriminated against federal officers because it exempted state officers. Still, many excessive force and false arrest cases involve conduct that is clearly unconstitutional under existing Ninth Circuit law. Those are the cases where Civil Code 53.8 will matter most.

How is this different from the Federal Tort Claims Act?

The Federal Tort Claims Act lets you sue the United States itself for certain wrongs by federal employees, including assault, battery, and false imprisonment by law enforcement officers. SB 747 lets you sue the individual agent for violating the Constitution. Many cases will use both, and each has its own rules and deadlines.

The FTCA has strict procedures. You must first file an administrative claim with the agency, usually on Standard Form 95, stating a specific dollar amount, within two years under 28 U.S.C. 2401(b). The agency then gets six months to respond before you can file suit. There is no jury in an FTCA case; a federal judge decides it.

A Civil Code 53.8 claim is aimed at the person who violated your rights. That changes the conversation. An agent who knows he can be named personally, and who knows the law shifts attorney fees to the winning plaintiff, has a reason to think twice before he “fails the attitude test” on your behalf.

What should you do if a federal agent violated your rights?

  1. Get medical care and photograph every injury within the first day, then again as bruising develops.
  2. Write down everything now: names, badge numbers, vehicle descriptions, the agency, the time, and the exact location.
  3. Find the witnesses and the video. Neighbors’ doorbell cameras, business security systems, and bystander phones are often the best evidence. Ask quickly; many systems overwrite in days.
  4. Do not sign anything or give a statement about the incident without a lawyer.
  5. Talk to a civil rights attorney promptly. The FTCA claim, any state government claim, and the Civil Code 53.8 suit each have different deadlines, and mixing them up can cost you a case.

If local police or deputies were involved alongside federal agents, which happens in task-force operations, there may also be a claim against the city or county. Those claims carry California’s six-month government claim deadline, which is far shorter than most people expect.

Is SB 747 going to be challenged in court?

Possibly. As of October 2, 2026, no federal lawsuit to block the law had been reported, though the U.S. Attorney for the Central District of California publicly criticized it. Expect the federal government to argue that states cannot regulate federal officers. I will not predict how that fight ends.

What I will tell you is this. When I wrote about SB 747 in August, in The No Kings Act: Can You Sue a Federal Agent in California?, it was still a bill. Now it is the law, and people are using it. If a federal agent violated your rights at any point since March 1, 2025, the clock is already running.

Talk to someone who has done this for four decades

Steering Law handles federal civil rights lawsuits against police and government agents throughout Southern California, from our office in Newport Beach. If you or a family member was hurt or wrongly detained by ICE, Border Patrol, or any other agency, call us at (949) 474-1849 for a consultation about your specific situation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Governor Newsom signed SB 747 on September 29, 2026. It took effect immediately and is codified at California Civil Code section 53.8.

Yes. It reaches constitutional violations that occurred on or after March 1, 2025.

A citizen held without probable cause may have a Fourth Amendment claim. Civil Code 53.8 now gives that person a California cause of action against the individual agent, in addition to any Federal Tort Claims Act claim against the United States.

A prevailing plaintiff may recover reasonable attorney fees, costs, and expert fees under the new law.

Yes. Defendants may raise qualified or absolute immunity to the same extent they could in a federal section 1983 case.

Generally two years from the incident, filed first as an administrative claim with the federal agency. A lawyer should confirm the deadline for your facts.

No. The law protects anyone whose constitutional rights are violated by a person acting under color of law, regardless of citizenship.

About the Author

Jerry L. Steering, Esq. has been suing police officers and defending bogus “resistance offense” criminal cases throughout California since 1984. A graduate of the University of Georgia School of Law (1984), he is admitted to practice in California, Georgia, the Ninth and Eleventh Circuits, and the United States Supreme Court. His police-misconduct cases have produced settlements and verdicts in the millions, and his work has been featured on ABC News, CNN, Good Morning America, Dateline NBC, The Washington Post, and the Los Angeles Times. He practices from Newport Beach and serves clients across Southern California.

Legal Disclaimer

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this post or contacting Steering Law through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different; if you are facing a legal issue, you should consult a qualified California attorney about your specific situation. Past results do not guarantee similar outcomes.

Sources
  1. California Legislative Information, SB 747 (2025-2026): https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?bill_id=202520260SB747
  2. Daily Journal, “US citizens invoke new California law against immigration agents,” Oct. 2, 2026: https://dailyjournal.com/article/394958-us-citizens-invoke-new-california-law-against-immigration-agents
  3. Fox LA, “3 Californians amend immigration lawsuits after ‘No Kings Act’ signed into law,” Oct. 1, 2026: https://www.foxla.com/news/3-californians-amend-immigration-lawsuits-after-no-kings-act-signed-law
  4. 42 U.S.C. 1983 (Cornell LII): https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/1983
  5. Federal Tort Claims Act, 28 U.S.C. 2401(b) and 2675 (Cornell LII): https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/28/2675
  6. Liebert Cassidy Whitmore, “Governor Newsom Signs Senate Bill 1004, Expanding the No Secret Police Act,” Oct. 6, 2026 (Feb. 9, 2026 ruling): https://www.calpublicagencylaboremploymentblog.com/legislation/governor-newsom-signs-senate-bill-1004-expanding-the-no-secret-police-act/
  7. Egbert v. Boule, 596 U.S. 482 (2022) (Justia): https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/596/21-147/

The California Racial Justice Act: When Race Played a Role in Your Case

For decades, challenging racial bias in a criminal case meant proving that someone meant to discriminate. Under the federal standard set in McCleskey v. Kemp (1987), statistical evidence of stark disparities was not enough. You had to show purposeful discrimination in your own case, which was close to impossible.

California changed that. If race, ethnicity, or national origin played a role in how you were charged, convicted, or sentenced, there is now a state law process for raising it.

QUICK ANSWER: The California Racial Justice Act, Penal Code section 745, lets a person challenge a charge, conviction, or sentence where race, ethnicity, or national origin played a role. You do not have to prove anyone intended to discriminate. Proof of bias by a judge, attorney, officer, expert, or juror, or of statistical disparities in charging or sentencing, can be enough. As of January 1, 2026, the law reaches felony convictions regardless of when they were entered.

What the law does

The California Racial Justice Act was enacted by AB 2542 in 2020 and is codified at Penal Code section 745. AB 256, passed in 2022, extended it to past convictions on a phased schedule.

The core provision is direct. The state may not seek or obtain a criminal conviction, or seek, obtain, or impose a sentence, on the basis of race, ethnicity, or national origin. Crucially, a violation can be shown without proving intentional discrimination, and the standard of proof is a preponderance of the evidence rather than anything higher.

The four ways a violation can be shown

Section 745(a) sets out four separate pathways.

Bias or animus by someone involved in the case

The judge, an attorney in the case, a law enforcement officer involved in the case, an expert witness, or a juror exhibited bias or animus toward the defendant based on race, ethnicity, or national origin. This covers conduct outside the courtroom, including things said on a recording, in a text message, or in a social media post.

Racially discriminatory language during the proceedings

During the trial proceedings, a judge, attorney, law enforcement officer, expert witness, or juror used racially discriminatory language about the defendant’s race, ethnicity, or national origin, or otherwise exhibited bias, whether or not it was purposeful.

Charging disparities

The defendant was charged with or convicted of a more serious offense than defendants of other races, ethnicities, or national origins who engaged in similar conduct and are similarly situated, and prosecutors more frequently sought that more serious charge against people who share the defendant’s race, ethnicity, or national origin in the county where the case was filed.

Sentencing disparities

A longer or more severe sentence was imposed than on similarly situated people of other races, ethnicities, or national origins, or a longer or more severe sentence was more frequently imposed on people who share the defendant’s background, or on defendants in cases with victims of a particular background, in the county where the sentence was imposed.

The third and fourth pathways are why this law is different from anything that came before. They are proved with data, not with a confession of prejudice.

Who can use it and when

AB 256 phased in retroactivity over four years:

  • January 1, 2023. People sentenced to death, and people facing immigration consequences such as deportation as a result of the conviction.
  • January 1, 2024. People currently serving a sentence in state prison, in county jail on a felony, or committed to the Division of Juvenile Justice.
  • January 1, 2025. People no longer incarcerated whose felony conviction or juvenile commitment was entered after January 1, 2015.
  • January 1, 2026. Everyone else with a felony conviction or juvenile commitment, regardless of when it was entered.

That final step has now arrived. As of this year the Act reaches felony convictions without regard to their date.

For a case that has not yet concluded, the claim is raised by motion in the trial court. For a case that is already final, it is generally raised through a petition for writ of habeas corpus or a motion under Penal Code section 1473, depending on custody status and posture.

The discovery provision people overlook

Section 745(d) allows a defendant who shows good cause to obtain discovery of records in the possession of the state or an agency that are relevant to a potential violation. In practice that can mean charging data, plea offer data, and sentencing data from the district attorney’s office in that county.

This provision is why the Act works. Without access to comparative data, the charging and sentencing pathways would be theoretical. With it, a defense team can test whether the pattern in a county matches what happened to one person.

Where police conduct fits in

The first two pathways expressly reach law enforcement officers involved in the case. That connects the Act directly to the records this firm works with regularly.

Under Penal Code section 832.7, as amended by SB 1421 and SB 16, sustained findings of dishonesty and of unreasonable force in an officer’s file are public records. Under the Racial and Identity Profiling Act, Government Code section 12525.5, agencies report stop data to the state, including the stated reason for each stop required by California’s reason for the stop law. Body camera audio captures what officers actually said.

A statement made on a recording during an arrest is exactly the kind of evidence the first two pathways were written to reach.

What relief looks like

Remedies depend on the stage of the case. Before judgment, a court may declare a mistrial, discharge the jury and empanel a new one, dismiss enhancements or special circumstances, or reduce charges. After conviction, a court may vacate the conviction or the sentence and order new proceedings.

Two things are worth saying plainly. A Racial Justice Act claim is fact intensive and evidence driven, and no lawyer can tell you at a first meeting how a court will rule. What a lawyer can do is tell you whether the record contains the kind of evidence the statute reaches.

Frequently asked questions

A state law, Penal Code section 745, that prohibits seeking or obtaining a criminal conviction or sentence on the basis of race, ethnicity, or national origin, and that allows a challenge without proof of intentional discrimination.

No. That requirement is what the Act removed. The standard is a preponderance of the evidence.

As of January 1, 2026, it reaches felony convictions and juvenile commitments regardless of when they were entered, following the phase in schedule set by AB 256.

The retroactivity provisions of AB 256 are framed around felony convictions and juvenile commitments. For a pending case, the Act applies at trial regardless of the level of the offense. How it applies to a particular past misdemeanor is a question for counsel.

Recorded or written statements by a judge, attorney, officer, expert, or juror; testimony; and statistical evidence of charging or sentencing disparities in the county, often obtained through the Act’s own discovery provision.

Yes. The statute expressly includes law enforcement officers involved in the case among the people whose bias or discriminatory language can establish a violation.

By motion in the trial court in a pending case, or generally by petition for writ of habeas corpus or under Penal Code section 1473 in a case that is already final.

It depends on the stage. Options range from dismissing enhancements or reducing charges before judgment to vacating a conviction or sentence afterward.

If you believe race played a role in how you were charged, tried, or sentenced in Southern California, the Law Office of Jerry L. Steering handles criminal defense matters from its Newport Beach office. Call (949) 474-1849 to discuss your case.

About the Author

Jerry L. Steering has defended criminal cases and litigated civil rights claims since 1984. He graduated from the University of Georgia School of Law in 1984 and has been licensed in California since 1986 (State Bar No. 122509). His Newport Beach practice covers criminal defense, police misconduct, and civil rights throughout Orange, Los Angeles, Riverside, San Bernardino, San Diego, Ventura, Santa Barbara, and Kern counties.

This article is general legal information, not legal advice about your situation. Reading it does not create an attorney client relationship.

Sources
  • California Penal Code section 745 (California Racial Justice Act of 2020)
  • AB 2542 (2019 to 2020 Regular Session), Racial Justice Act of 2020
  • AB 256 (2021 to 2022 Regular Session), Criminal procedure: discrimination
  • California Penal Code section 1473
  • McCleskey v. Kemp, 481 U.S. 279 (1987)
  • Office of the State Public Defender, “AB 256 Racial Justice Act Retroactivity,” February 2023
  • Judge J. Richard Couzens, “California Racial Justice Act of 2020,” April 2024
  • California Penal Code section 832.7, as amended by SB 1421 and SB 16
  • California Government Code section 12525.5
Calexico Police SWAT

When a Welfare Check Turns Violent: Police Force During a Mental Health Crisis

Most families in this situation made the call themselves.

Someone was in crisis, or off their medication, or talking about hurting themselves, and the family did what they were told to do. They called for help. What arrived was armed. Minutes later someone they love was injured, or gone.

If that is your family, the guilt you are carrying is not yours to carry. You asked for help for a person in medical distress. What happened next was a set of choices made by people who are trained, paid, and equipped to make them differently.

This article explains what California law actually allows in these cases. It is general information, not advice about your situation.

QUICK ANSWER: Yes, a family can bring a case. Three theories usually apply together in California: a Fourth Amendment excessive force claim under 42 U.S.C. section 1983, a state negligence claim that reaches the officers’ tactics before force was used, and a claim under Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act for failing to reasonably accommodate a known disability. A written government claim is generally due within six months.

Three claims that work together

The federal excessive force claim

Under 42 U.S.C. section 1983, force by an officer is judged against the Fourth Amendment’s objective reasonableness standard from Graham v. Connor (1989). Courts weigh the severity of the offense, whether the person posed an immediate threat, and whether they were actively resisting or fleeing.

An important change arrived recently. In Barnes v. Felix, 145 S. Ct. 1353 (2025), a unanimous Supreme Court rejected the “moment of threat” approach, under which some courts looked only at the final seconds before force was used. The Court held that reasonableness is judged on the totality of the circumstances, which includes what led up to the encounter.

For crisis cases that holding matters enormously, because so much of what goes wrong happens in the minutes before anyone is touched.

The California negligence claim

California law has been ahead of federal law on this point for years. In Hayes v. County of San Diego (2013) 57 Cal.4th 622, the California Supreme Court held that an officer’s pre-shooting tactical conduct and decisions are part of the totality of circumstances a jury may consider in a negligence claim.

Put plainly: under California law a jury can be asked whether it was reasonable to approach the way they did, to shout competing commands, to close distance quickly, to skip a request for a crisis team, or to escalate when time and cover were available. That is often the strongest claim a family has.

The disability discrimination claim

Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act, 42 U.S.C. section 12132, applies to police arrests in the Ninth Circuit. Two theories are recognized.

The first is wrongful arrest, where officers mistake the effects of a disability for criminal conduct. The second is failure to accommodate, where officers arrest or detain someone lawfully but fail to reasonably accommodate a known disability during the encounter.

Sheehan v. City and County of San Francisco (9th Cir. 2014) established that Title II reaches arrests, and Vos v. City of Newport Beach (9th Cir. 2018) applied it in a case involving a man in psychiatric crisis. Courts have generally treated the reasonableness of an accommodation as a question of fact, which means these claims often survive to a jury rather than being resolved on paper.

What “accommodation” looks like in practice

Families sometimes hear the word accommodation and picture something abstract. In these cases it is concrete and it is usually about time and distance.

  • Slowing the encounter down when there is no immediate threat to anyone else.
  • Using one officer as the single communicator rather than several people shouting at once.
  • Keeping cover and distance rather than closing on a person who is frightened.
  • Requesting a crisis intervention trained officer, a mental health clinician, or a mobile crisis team.
  • Actually using the information the family gave the dispatcher about the diagnosis, the medication, the triggers, and what has worked before.

That last point is where many of these cases begin. The family told the dispatcher exactly what was happening. Whether that information reached the responding officers, and what they did with it, is one of the first things to investigate.

None of this requires an officer to walk into danger. Courts have consistently recognized that officers may protect themselves and others, and that they often have to decide quickly with incomplete information. The question in these cases is narrower and fairer than it is sometimes made out to be. When there was time, cover, distance, and a trained resource available, were those things used, and if not, why not?

What to do in the days after

These are practical steps, and there is a clock on some of them.

  • Send a written preservation demand to the agency for all body worn camera and dash camera video, the 911 audio, the computer aided dispatch logs, and the radio traffic. The dispatch record is often the single most important document.
  • Request the critical incident video. If an officer fired a weapon, or force caused death or great bodily injury, Government Code section 7923.625 generally requires release within 45 days, with limited grounds for delay. Our guide on how to obtain body camera footage explains the process.
  • Request the officers’ conduct records under Penal Code section 832.7, as amended by SB 1421 and SB 16.
  • Get an independent autopsy if a death occurred and the family is able to. Coroner findings can be contested.
  • Watch the six month deadline. A claim against a California public entity generally must be presented in writing within six months under Government Code section 911.2. Federal claims have a longer window, but the state claim deadline arrives fast and it is strict.

A note on getting help

If you or someone you love is in crisis right now, the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline is available by call or text, and many California counties operate mobile crisis teams that respond without police. Families sometimes tell us they did not know a non police option existed in their county. It is worth finding out what yours offers before you need it.

Frequently asked questions

Often yes. California cases commonly combine a federal excessive force claim, a state negligence claim reaching the officers’ tactics, and a Title II ADA claim. Whether any of them fits depends entirely on the facts.

In the Ninth Circuit, which covers California, Title II applies to arrests. Sheehan and Vos are the leading decisions.

The federal standard asks whether the force was objectively reasonable under the Fourth Amendment. California negligence law allows a jury to consider the officers’ pre-force tactical conduct as well, under Hayes v. County of San Diego.

No. Calling for help does not excuse an unreasonable response, and the content of that call is frequently important evidence about what officers knew.

Generally six months to present a written government claim to a California public entity, under Government Code section 911.2. Federal section 1983 claims borrow California’s two year personal injury period. The six month deadline is the urgent one.

California law limits wrongful death claims to specified categories of relatives, and a separate survival action belongs to the estate. Which applies depends on the family’s circumstances.

The 911 audio and dispatch logs, all body camera and dash camera video, the radio traffic, the use of force reports, and the officers’ conduct records under Penal Code section 832.7.

It can. Training, or its absence, is relevant to the negligence analysis, to the accommodation question under the ADA, and to any claim against the agency itself for failure to train.

If your family is dealing with the aftermath of a crisis call in Southern California, the Law Office of Jerry L. Steering handles excessive force and wrongful death cases against law enforcement. You can reach the Newport Beach office at (949) 474-1849.

About the Author

Jerry L. Steering has represented people injured by law enforcement, and the families of people killed by law enforcement, since 1984. He graduated from the University of Georgia School of Law in 1984 and has been licensed in California since 1986 (State Bar No. 122509). His Newport Beach practice covers police misconduct, civil rights, and criminal defense throughout Orange, Los Angeles, Riverside, San Bernardino, San Diego, Ventura, Santa Barbara, and Kern counties.

This article is general legal information, not legal advice about your situation. Reading it does not create an attorney client relationship.

Sources
  • Graham v. Connor, 490 U.S. 386 (1989)
  • Barnes v. Felix, 145 S. Ct. 1353 (2025)
  • Hayes v. County of San Diego (2013) 57 Cal.4th 622
  • Sheehan v. City and County of San Francisco, 743 F.3d 1211 (9th Cir. 2014)
  • Vos v. City of Newport Beach, 892 F.3d 1024 (9th Cir. 2018)
  • 42 U.S.C. section 12132 (Title II, Americans with Disabilities Act)
  • 42 U.S.C. section 1983
  • California Government Code sections 911.2 and 7923.625
  • California Penal Code section 832.7, as amended by SB 1421 and SB 16
  • Advocate Magazine, “Understanding disability rights litigation in police misconduct and jail detention cases,” June 2024
  • 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline
Calexico Police officer arresting civilian

Suing the City, Not Just the Officer: Monell Claims in California

People are often surprised to learn that suing the officer and suing the department are two different lawsuits with two different sets of rules.

If a deputy broke your arm during an arrest, the claim against that deputy is one thing. The claim against the county that trained him, supervised him, reviewed his prior uses of force, and cleared him each time is something else. Understanding the difference explains why some cases name a single officer and others name a city, a police chief, and a department all at once.

QUICK ANSWER: A city or county is not automatically liable for what its officers do. Under Monell v. Department of Social Services (1978), a public entity is liable under 42 U.S.C. section 1983 only when its own policy, longstanding custom, failure to train, or a final policymaker’s decision caused the violation. The tradeoff is significant: qualified immunity protects individual officers, but it does not protect the entity.

The rule that starts everything

In Monell v. Department of Social Services of the City of New York, 436 U.S. 658 (1978), the Supreme Court held that municipalities are “persons” who can be sued under section 1983. In the same decision it closed a door. A city cannot be held liable simply because it employs someone who violated your rights.

The legal shorthand is that there is no respondeat superior liability under section 1983. In ordinary employment law, an employer is generally responsible for what an employee does on the job. Section 1983 does not work that way. To reach the entity, you have to show the entity itself did something.

The four routes to entity liability

Courts generally recognize four ways to get there.

An official policy

The most direct route, and the rarest. A written policy, ordinance, or regulation that itself causes the constitutional violation. Departments rarely write down anything this useful, but policies on things like when to deploy a police dog, when to use a carotid restraint, or how long to hold someone before arraignment sometimes do the work.

A longstanding custom or practice

More common, and harder to prove. Here the argument is that a practice is so widespread and settled that it has the force of policy even though nobody wrote it down. This is built from patterns: repeated incidents of the same kind, complaints that were consistently dismissed, uses of force that were consistently found to be within policy.

Failure to train or supervise

Under City of Canton v. Harris, 489 U.S. 378 (1989), a failure to train can be a basis for liability where that failure amounts to deliberate indifference to the rights of people the officers encounter. The Supreme Court set a demanding standard in Connick v. Thompson, 563 U.S. 51 (2011), generally requiring a pattern of similar violations that put the entity on notice, with a narrow exception for situations where the need for training is patently obvious.

Ratification by a final policymaker

Under Pembaur v. City of Cincinnati, 475 U.S. 469 (1986), a single decision by an official with final policymaking authority can bind the entity. In police cases this often takes the shape of a ratification argument: a chief or sheriff reviewed a use of force, knew the facts, and approved both the conduct and the reasoning behind it.

Why this matters when qualified immunity is in the case

Qualified immunity shields an individual officer from damages unless the right violated was clearly established at the time. It is the single most frustrating doctrine in this area of law, and we have written about it at length in our discussion of qualified immunity and SB 2.

Here is the part that gets overlooked. Qualified immunity is a personal defense. Municipalities do not get it. An entity cannot argue that its policy was not clearly established as unconstitutional in the way an individual officer can argue about their own conduct.

That does not make entity claims easy. The causation and deliberate indifference showings are genuinely difficult. But it does mean the entity claim can survive in cases where the individual claim is at its weakest, and that is not a small thing.

The evidence these cases are built from

Monell claims are won with records, and a striking amount of the relevant material is public or obtainable.

  • Peace officer conduct records. Penal Code section 832.7, as amended by SB 1421 and SB 16, makes several categories public, including sustained findings of dishonesty and of unreasonable force, and records of uses of force causing death or great bodily injury.
  • Critical incident video. Government Code section 7923.625 requires release of video from shootings and serious force incidents within 45 days, subject to limited delays.
  • Stop data. Agencies report stop information to the California Department of Justice under the Racial and Identity Profiling Act.
  • Training materials, policy manuals, and use of force reviews, obtained in discovery once a case is filed.
  • Prior complaints and prior lawsuits against the same agency and the same officers.
  • Audits, consent decrees, grand jury reports, and inspector general findings where they exist.

The picture that emerges from those records is either a department that identified a problem and corrected it, or a department that saw the same thing happen repeatedly and did nothing. That contrast is the heart of a Monell case.

California adds a second track

Federal law is not the only option. Under California’s Tom Bane Civil Rights Act, Civil Code section 52.1, public entities can be vicariously liable for their employees’ conduct under state law principles, which is a meaningfully different structure from Monell. Many cases plead both, and our article on qualified immunity versus the Bane Act walks through why.

There is a deadline that comes with the state law track. A claim against a California public entity generally must be presented in writing within six months under Government Code section 911.2. Federal section 1983 claims in California borrow the state’s two year personal injury limitations period, but the six month claim requirement is the one that catches people.

One more development worth knowing

In Barnes v. Felix, 145 S. Ct. 1353 (2025), a unanimous Supreme Court rejected the “moment of threat” approach that some courts had used to evaluate police force by looking only at the final seconds before it was used. Courts must consider the totality of the circumstances, including what led up to the encounter.

That matters for entity claims, because tactics, training, and decisions made minutes earlier are now squarely part of the analysis rather than something a court can wave away.

Frequently asked questions

A claim under 42 U.S.C. section 1983 against a city, county, or other public entity, based on the entity’s own policy, custom, failure to train, or a final policymaker’s decision, rather than on the fact that it employed the officer.

No. Section 1983 does not allow liability based on the employment relationship alone. You have to connect the harm to the entity’s own policy, custom, training failure, or ratification.

No. Qualified immunity is a defense available to individual officials, not to public entities.

A demanding standard meaning the entity knew of, or the need was obvious as to, a risk of constitutional violations and consciously disregarded it. It is more than negligence.

Usually through public records requests under Penal Code section 832.7, prior complaints and lawsuits, agency policies and training materials obtained in discovery, and stop and use of force data.

Sometimes, under the narrow route recognized in Canton and Pembaur, for example where a final policymaker made or ratified the decision, or where the need for particular training was patently obvious. Most cases still rest on a pattern.

The California government claim requirement, generally six months under Government Code section 911.2, applies to state law claims against public entities. Federal section 1983 claims in California borrow a two year limitations period. Both can be running at once.

That depends entirely on the facts and the available records. Many cases name both, because the claims are governed by different rules and can succeed or fail independently.

If you are considering a case against a police department or sheriff’s department in Southern California, the Law Office of Jerry L. Steering handles federal civil rights lawsuits against officers and the entities that employ them. Call the Newport Beach office at (949) 474-1849.

About the Author

Jerry L. Steering has represented people injured by law enforcement since 1984. He graduated from the University of Georgia School of Law in 1984 and has been licensed in California since 1986 (State Bar No. 122509). His Newport Beach practice covers police misconduct, civil rights, and criminal defense throughout Orange, Los Angeles, Riverside, San Bernardino, San Diego, Ventura, Santa Barbara, and Kern counties.

This article is general legal information, not legal advice about your situation. Reading it does not create an attorney client relationship.

Sources
  • Monell v. Department of Social Services, 436 U.S. 658 (1978)
  • City of Canton v. Harris, 489 U.S. 378 (1989)
  • Pembaur v. City of Cincinnati, 475 U.S. 469 (1986)
  • Connick v. Thompson, 563 U.S. 51 (2011)
  • Barnes v. Felix, 145 S. Ct. 1353 (2025)
  • 42 U.S.C. section 1983
  • California Civil Code section 52.1 (Tom Bane Civil Rights Act)
  • California Government Code section 911.2
  • California Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1
  • California Penal Code section 832.7, as amended by SB 1421 and SB 16
  • California Government Code sections 7923.625 and 12525.5