Skip to content
  • Los Angeles County
  • Riverside County
  • Orange County
  • San Bernardino County
  • San Diego County
  • The Lawyer’s Lounge
Police Misconduct Attorney - Southern California
  • Police Misconduct Attorney
    4063 Birch Street, Suite 100
    Newport Beach, CA 92660
  • Phone: (949) 474-1849
    Available 24 Hours a Day
    jerry@steeringlaw.com
  • Free Case Evaluation

Police Misconduct Attorney

4063 Birch Street Suite 100, Newport Beach, CA 92660Phone: 949-474-1849 | Available 24 Hours A Day!
  • Home
  • Civil Rights Lawyer
    • Civil Rights Attorney
    • Police Misconduct Specialist; Suing Bad Cops And Defending Bogus…
    • Jerry L. Steering, Esq. – Specialist In Suing Police Officers
    • 42 U.S.C. § 1983 Lawsuits; Suing State Actors for Violating Federal…
      • Suing Police Officers For Violating Your Constitutional Rights
    • Four Steps to Curbing Police Misconduct in the United States
    • Police Misconduct Is Rampant And Condoned By Modern Police Agencies
    • The “Contempt of Cop Game”; How Well Can You Play?
    • How The Exclusionary Rule Backfired And Crushed Americans’ Constitutional Rights.
    • Why American’s Civil Rights Are Going, Going, Gone
    • Suing Police Officers For Violating Your Constitutional Rights
    • What To Do If You Have Been Beaten-Up or Falsely Arrested By The Police
    • Suing the Police for False Arrest in Southern California
    • Why The Police Don’t Want Their Conduct Recorded
    • Police Misconduct Lawsuits in California
    • Dirty Harry And The Criminal Procedure Counter-Revolution
    • Why The Police Are Not Our Friends Anymore
    • Can You Sue The Police For Malicious Criminal Prosecutions?
    • Is It A Crime To Refuse To Identify Yourself to a Police Officer in California?
    • The Ninth Amendment Shows that “Originalist” Constitutional Interpretation is a Fraud
    • The D.A. Can Do No Wrong; Prosecutorial Immunity And The Police State
    • The Modern Police State: “Officer’s Safety” Replaces “Probable Cause”
    • Why Grand Juries Don’t Indict Police Officers?
    • Why the cops get away with it; the jury system
    • “The Law Is Crazy” – Public Misperception Of The Exclusionary Rule
    • Today’s Police Can Beat Or Kill Anyone, Anytime They Desire
    • Police Brutality In Modern America; Its Root And Causes
      • Today’s Police Can Beat Or Kill Anyone, Anytime They Desire
      • Long Beach Police Brutaltity Excessive Force Attorney
      • San Bernardino County Brutality & Excessive Force Attorney
        • Jurupa Valley Police Brutality – Excessive Force Attorney
        • Rancho Cucamonga & Chino, CA Police Misconduct Attorney
  • Criminal Defense
    • Southern California Resisting Arrest Attorney
    • Police Brutality Is Encouraged By Bogus Resisting Arrest & Battery On Officer Prosecutions
    • California Penal Code Section 148(a)(1) Lawyer
    • Cal. Penal Code Section 69; The Hammer Of Oppression
    • Mr. Steering Obtains “Sweetheart Deal” For Deputies’ Misconduct
    • Resisting Arrest Cases California Lawyer
    • Criminal Law Practice – Generally
      • Santa Ana, CA Criminal Attorney
    • The Scam Of Discovery In California Criminal Cases
    • “The Law Is Crazy” – Public Misperception Of The Exclusionary Rule
    • Why the cops get away with it; the jury system
    • Cal. Penal Code Section 240; Simple Assault Lawyer
    • Cal. Health & Safety Code Section 11379, Sale of Controlled Substances
    • Cal. Health & Safety Code Section 11378; Possession of Controlled Substances for Sale
    • Cal. Health & Safety Code Section 11352 – Sale of Controlled Substances
    • Cal. Health & Safety Code Section 11377, Possession of Methamphetamine
    • Cal. Health & Safety Code Section 11350, Possession of Controlled Substances Lawyer
    • Cal. Health & Safety Code Section 11365, Drug Loitering
    • Cal. Health & Safety Code Section 11379.6, Drug Manufacturing
    • Brady List and Pitchess Motions
    • Criminal Towing Industry Cases
    • How To Win Your Drug Case; Go After the Cops
    • Notable San Bernardino County Criminal to Civil Rights Cases
    • Criminal Towing Cases
  • Police Brutality & Shootings
    • Police Brutality In Modern America; Its Root And Causes
    • Police Brutality Is Encouraged By Bogus Resisting Arrest & Battery On Officer Prosecutions
    • Police Brutality Lawyer, Southern California
      • Santa Ana, CA Police Brutality Attorney
      • Anaheim Police Brutality Attorney
      • Huntington Beach Police Brutality Attorney
      • Rancho Cucamonga – Chino Police False Arrest Attorney
      • Victorville – Apple Valley Police Brutality Attorney
    • Excessive Force Attorney
      • County of Orange Excessive Force Attorney
      • Excessive Force & Police Brutality Attorney – Los Angeles California
      • Garden Grove, CA Police Brutality Attorney
      • Huntington Beach Police Brutality Attorney
      • Jurupa Valley Police Brutality – Excessive Force Attorney
      • Oceanside, California Police Brutality Attorney
      • Palm Springs Police Brutality Attorney
      • Rancho Cucamonga – Chino Police Brutality Attorney
      • San Bernardino County Brutality & Excessive Force Attorney
      • San Diego County Police Brutality & Excessive Force Attorney
      • Santa Ana, CA Police Brutality Attorney
      • Victorville – Apple Valley Police Brutality Attorney
    • California Police Wrongful Death Cases
    • California Police Excessive Force Lawyer Cases
    • California Police Wrongful Death Cases
    • Taser Victim Attorrney
      • Tasers Cases
    • Anaheim Pays $2,900,000 for Police Shooting of Motorist During
    • Barstow Pays 1.3 Million Dollars for 2018 Police Shooting at the Sands Motel
    • Four Steps to Curbing Police Misconduct in the United States
    • Police Misconduct and Other Civil Rights Case Results
    • Fontana, CA Police Misconduct Attorney Jerry L. Steering
    • Why The Police Are Not Our Friends Anymore
    • “The Law Is Crazy” – Public Misperception Of The Exclusionary Rule
    • Suing Police Officers For Violating Your Constitutional Rights
    • How to Sue the Police Department in California?
    • The “Contempt of Cop Game”; How Well Can You Play?
    • Resisting Arrest Cases California Lawyer
    • California Penal Code Section 148(a)(1) Lawyer
    • Cal. Penal Code Section 69; The Hammer Of Oppression
    • Why Grand Juries Don’t Indict Police Officers?
    • The “Contempt of Cop Game”; How Well Can You Play?
    • Why the cops get away with it; the jury system
    • The D.A. Can Do No Wrong; Prosecutorial Immunity And The Police State
    • California Penal Code Section 148(a)(1) Lawyer
    • Cal. Penal Code Section 69; The Hammer Of Oppression
    • Suing the Police for False Arrest in Southern California
    • Rancho Cucamonga – Chino Police False Arrest Attorney
    • Suing Police Officers For Violating Your Constitutional Rights
    • Civil Rights Attorney
    • San Bernardino County Brutality & Excessive Force Attorney
    • Rancho Cucamonga – Chino Police False Arrest Attorney
    • Rancho Cucamonga – Chino Police False Arrest Attorney
    • Santa Ana, CA Criminal Attorney
    • Jurupa Valley Criminal Attorney
    • Jurupa Valley Police Brutality – Excessive Force Attorney
    • Rancho Cucamonga – Chino Police False Arrest Attorney
    • Jurupa Valley Criminal Attorney
    • Suing the Police for False Arrest in Southern California
    • Apple Valley, CA Police Misconduct Attorney
    • Buena Park, CA Police Misconduct Attorney
    • Chino Hills, CA Police Misconduct Attorney
    • Chula Vista Police Misconduct Attorney & Specialist
    • Coronado, CA Police Misconduct Attorney
    • Desert Hot Springs Police Misconduct Attorney
    • Huntington Beach, CA Police Misconduct Attorney
    • Indio, CA Police Misconduct Attorney
    • Jurupa Valley Police Misconduct Attorney
    • Laguna Beach, CA Police Misconduct Attorney Cases
    • Mission Viejo, CA Police Misconduct Attorney
    • Oceanside Police Misconduct Attorney & Specialist
    • Oceanside Police Misconduct Attorney
    • Ontario, CA Police Misconduct Attorney
    • Orange County, California Police Misconduct Attorney
    • Palm Springs, CA Police Misconduct Attorney
    • Santa Ana, CA Police Misconduct Attorney
    • Huntington Beach Police Misconduct Cases
    • Rancho Cucamonga – Chino Police False Arrest Attorney
  • Resisting Arrest 69 & 148(a)(1)
    • If You’re The Victim; You’re The Enemy
    • California Penal Code Section 148(a)(1) Lawyer
    • Cal. Penal Code Section 69; The Hammer Of Oppression
    • The “Contempt of Cop Game”; How Well Can You Play?
    • Suing Police Officers For Violating Your Constitutional Rights
    • Civil Rights Attorney
  • Case Results
    • Our Case Results
    • Mr. Steering Wins 21 Year Battle; Police Have No Right to Detain Bystanders to Arrest Warrant Executions or Probation and Parole Searches
    • Deputy can be sued for excessive force for shooting a suspect and then stomping on his head
    • Anaheim Pays $2,900,000 for Police Shooting of Motorist During
    • Family gets $2.1 million in jail death
    • Barstow Pays 1.3 Million Dollars for 2018 Police Shooting at the Sands Motel
    • Family of man shot in Anaheim, CA by the police department collects nearly $1 million in wrongful death settlement
    • $800,000 paid to Garden Grove stroke victim mistakenly arrested for DUI
    • County of Orange Pays $727,500.00 To Settle Civil Rights Lawsuit
    • Man Awarded $500,000 for tasing by OC deputies for calling 911 to complain about them
    • San Diego County settles sheriff’s deputy beating lawsuit for $500,000.00
    • Jerry L. Steering obtains $450,000 from Riverside County for False Arrest of bystander by Deputies
    • Man stunned by deputies in his bedroom gets $380,000
    • Newport Beach Falsely Arresting Woman Over a $16 Cab Ride. Jerry L. Steering Obtains $360,000 for Victim.
    • Jerry L. Steering’s Most Notable Orange County Police Misconduct Cases

Jerry L. Steering Wins Landmark "Special Needs School Arrest" Case In 9th Circuit Court of Appeals

Suing police officers and defending bogus criminal cases since 1984

Federal court says deputy shouldn’t have arrested Etiwanda girls ‘to teach them a lesson’

The Etiwanda School District office
The Etiwanda School District office in Rancho Cucamonga, CA.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

By Beau Yarbrough | byarbrough@scng.com | Inland Valley Daily Bulletin
PUBLISHED: September 10, 2018 at 7:01 pm | UPDATED: September 11, 2018 at 2:39 pm

A San Bernardino County sheriff’s deputy violated the Fourth Amendment rights of a group of Etiwanda Intermediate students when he arrested them because he thought they were uncooperative in a bullying investigation, a federal appeals court ruled Monday, Sept. 10.

“The summary arrest, handcuffing, and police transport to the station of the middle school girls was a disproportionate response to the school’s need, which was dissipation of what the school officials characterized as an ‘ongoing feud’ and ‘continuous argument’ between the students,” Judge Jacqueline H. Nguyen wrote in the opinion for the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals’ three-judge panel.

“No reasonable officer could have reasonably believed that the law authorizes the arrest of a group of middle schoolers in order to teach them a lesson or to prove a point,” the opinion said. The case goes back to Oct. 8, 2013, when a group of seventh-grade girls, ages 12 and 13, were handcuffed, arrested and driven from the school to the police station.

Balbina Kendall, then the school’s assistant principal, had asked the school resource officer, San Bernardino County sheriff’s Deputy Luis Ortiz for help with a group of girls who had been involved in bullying and fighting at school.

The seven girls were put in a classroom together. According to Nguyen’s opinion, Ortiz intended to verify what he had been told about the incidents by school administrators, but found the girls  “unresponsive and disrespectful.”

According to the court, an audio tape has some whispering and quiet giggling from some of the girls. The two girls who appear to have been the aggressors in the bullying, told Ortiz that they would not stop their behavior. But the other girls didn’t say anything until after Ortiz had started making arrests and asked if they needed to be handcuffed.

Ortiz told the girls he was arresting them because he was not “playing around” and was taking them to jail to “prove a point” and “make (them) mature a lot faster,” according to the opinion.

He did not care who was at fault, he told the girls, because it was the “same ticket, same pair of handcuffs.” According to the mother of one of the girls, Kendall said it was school policy to suspend any student involved in a fight, regardless of who was at fault.

The San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department declined to comment on Tuesday, with a spokeswoman citing “continuing mediation and litigation.”

Ultimately, the school did not discipline any of the seven girls, and no criminal charges were filed.

The Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution protects the public from “unreasonable search or seizure” or arrest without probable cause.

“The district follows its discipline policies and the California Education Code with respect to student discipline,” Etiwanda School District Superintendent Shawn Judson wrote in a statement Monday. “We partner with local law enforcement agencies to keep our schools safe. This approach has not changed significantly in the last five years; however, we continually review our policies and practices to ensure they effectively serve our students and school community.”

The families of three of the girls sued the arresting deputies and the County of San Bernardino for unlawful arrest in violation of state laws and the Fourth Amendment. (The suit against one of the deputies was later dropped.)

The district court denied the defendants qualified immunity and granted summary judgment in favor of the students.

“This is a published opinion. It’s not just an appeal. It’s going to have a really big impact on schools anywhere west of Utah,” said Newport Beach attorney Jerry Steering, who represented the families. “The people they have as school resource officers are not well-trained. This guy was a bad egg.”

A year after he arrested the girls at Etiwanda Intermediate,  Ortiz made headlines in 2014 when he accused a bullying victim of being an aggressor in a report. The student was suspended until video later emerged showing that the Etiwanda High victim had not fought back.

Now that the 9th Circuit Court has weighed in, the case will likely return to U.S. District Court Judge Virginia Phillips to determine damages, either through settlement or a special jury. In his original 2014 lawsuit, Steering had asked for $10 million in punitive damages and $10 million in compensatory damages.

Staff writers Ryan Hagen and Joe Nelson contributed to this story.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ultimately, the school did not discipline any of the seven girls, and no criminal charges were filed.

The Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution protects the public from “unreasonable search or seizure” or arrest without probable cause.

“The district follows its discipline policies and the California Education Code with respect to student discipline,” Etiwanda School District Superintendent Shawn Judson wrote in a statement Monday. “We partner with local law enforcement agencies to keep our schools safe. This approach has not changed significantly in the last five years; however, we continually review our policies and practices to ensure they effectively serve our students and school community.”

The families of three of the girls sued the arresting deputies and the County of San Bernardino for unlawful arrest in violation of state laws and the Fourth Amendment. (The suit against one of the deputies was later dropped.)

The district court denied the defendants qualified immunity and granted summary judgment in favor of the students.

“This is a published opinion. It’s not just an appeal. It’s going to have a really big impact on schools anywhere west of Utah,” said Newport Beach attorney Jerry Steering, who represented the families. “The people they have as school resource officers are not well-trained. This guy was a bad egg.”

A year after he arrested the girls at Etiwanda Intermediate,  Ortiz made headlines in 2014 when he accused a bullying victim of being an aggressor in a report. The student was suspended until video later emerged showing that the Etiwanda High victim had not fought back.

Now that the 9th Circuit Court has weighed in, the case will likely return to U.S. District Court Judge Virginia Phillips to determine damages, either through settlement or a special jury. In his original 2014 lawsuit, Steering had asked for $10 million in punitive damages and $10 million in compensatory damages.

Staff writers Ryan Hagen and Joe Nelson contributed to this story.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Mr. Steering Obtains "Sweetheart Deal" in Murder Case for Deputies' Misconduct
Read Case Details »

Jerry L. Steering


Civil Rights Lawyer Specializing in Police Misconduct and Criminal Defense; Suing Police Officers and Others for Violating Your Federal Constitutional Rights. Make the wrong step and you are out. We know where to step.

Free Case Evaluation
Article: What To Do If You Have Been Beaten-Up or Falsely Arrested By The Police?
You May Also Like These
Why The Police Don’t Want
Their Conduct Recorded
Contempt of Cop/Resisting Arrest Cases
Why The Police Are Not Our Friends Anymore
Read More Articles »
Good Morning America:
Jerry L. Steering with Diane Sawyer

Watch Video »

Police Awards & Settlements:
Eliuth Penaloza Nava v. City of Anaheim 2020; $2,900,000.00 for wrongful death
Danny Eatherton v. Riverside 2020; $450,000.00 false arrest

Ashley Watts v. Newport Beach 2020; $360,000.00 false arrest
Alexis Segovia v. Cathedral City, U.S. District Court (Riverside) 2017; $225,000.00 for false arrest
Robert Pitt v. County of San Diego, U.S. District Court (San Diego) 2017; $220,000.00 for false arrest
In re D.D.; U.S. District Court (LA) 2017; $300,000.00 for false arrest / unreasonable force
More Awards & Settlements »

About Steering Law Firm

Police Misconduct Attorney, Jerry L. Steering has handled hundreds of police misconduct civil rights cases and defended bogus criminal cases since 1984. False arrest, unreasonable force and malicious prosecution cases are a legal minefield; make the wrong step and you are out. We know where to step.

Steering Law

Law Office of Jerry L. Steering
4063 Birch Street, Suite 100
Newport Beach, CA 92660
Tel: (949) 474-1849
Fax: (949) 474-1883
Email: jerry@steeringlaw.com

Police Misconduct Areas

Concealing Evidence
Destroying Evidence
Excessive Force
False Arrest
K-9 Maulings
Malicious Prosecution
Police Beatings
Police Brutality
Police Shootings
Whistle Blower Retaliation
Wrongful Death
  •  

  •